so there’s 4 timelines: the first being carcel and ines being together but because of the complications with her health/pregnancy that timeline was short lived. the second timeline was when ines committed due to the cp’s atrocious acts, the third being emiliano and ines tragic love and the fourth being the current timeline, yes?
i saw in the comments that the cp is aware of all the timelines, but from what i understand ines only knows the 2nd and 3rd timeline, and emiliano knows the 3rd timeline, whereas carcel is a special case. is there a reason why the 1st timeline is forgotten??
pls help a girl out thank you ( ̄▽ ̄;)
Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer
The first timeline is actually very tragic and hard to read. Most people try to skip it because Ines just kept losing everything she loved. She was also suffering from terminal illness and the death of her children so it’s very angst-like and tragic read. Both her and Carcel died at the same moment. He died on the battlefield and Ines had prayed she would die the same moment as him if he dies first. So the Apostle granted her wish and she died the same time Carcel was killed on the battlefield. Ines also bore children but this BITCH was poisoning her and her children. Her first child died when he was almost 10 months so he is still her longest living child up to this point in the story.
2nd TL: married to cp
3rd TL: married to painter
4th TL: married to Carcel
CP has memories of all timelines. Ines just got new memories of the first true TL in ep95 & 96.
First TL is forgotten because neither Ines nor Carcel made wishes for memories. Ines used her wishes for Carcel and Carcel used his wishes for Ines. CP used his wishes for himself by asking for memories to commit revenge on Luciano who legitimately killed him by moving the country to depose him.










yall sorry i overlooked the scandal part. what exactly did seo-in think happened/believe from the news? like who does he think is the bully and the victim since he isn’t aware that it’s yw?
i’m pretty sure the article’s about a “bullying scandal” by seo-in’s brother which seo-in isn’t surprised by bc his brother was so messed up, but the article never mentioned yw so seo-in thinks it’s a way for people to blackmail him and claim he was the bully
ooohh okay gotcha. thanks!
The scandal is that Seo-in bullied and beat up a kid when he was in highschool. The one that did it was that fucking bitch of his step-brother and the victim was Yeong-woon.
He said that the scandal doesn't have anything to do with him because that's the truth, he didn't do anything (Seo-in's step-mom getting panicked when she saw Yeog-woon, and how the money Yeong-woon had to run away from his father was given to him by her to shut him up).
He doesn't know the victim was Yeong-woon...he doesn't even know why Yeong-woon suddenly disappeared one day without reaching out to him.
I didn’t quite get that part either. I think the author hasn’t made it clear yet. Personally, I think Seoin might have assumed that the article mentioned his brother’s past bullying scandal from their school days and that it was being linked to him as well. Or maybe the article was only about his brothe but it’s not clear whether it’s actually connected to YW. Another possibility is that Seoin didn’t read the whole article and just skimmed through it.