Uhh

Mint January 17, 2021 9:24 am

Usually promos do have better art because the artist can go all out since it's only one chapter and they're paid well

Serialised webtoons need to have a simpler style because the artist has to draw a LOT for a LONG TIME and CONSISTENTLY and the pay per chapter is much lesser

Saying the other version is not as beautiful is a little inconsiderate imo

Responses
    Maddie January 17, 2021 2:24 pm

    yes, the art style from the other version is different from this, doesn't mean that it's inferior, both are beautiful and i appreciate the one behind the art:)

    Anonymous January 28, 2021 2:20 am

    I mean— obviously we know that promo art is usually better because it’s going to be short it’s just one chapter after all
    I wouldn't say that serialized work has a “simpler” style it’s just that the artists have different art styles
    Plus— by you saying promo art is better because artists “go all out” because its a promo you’re kind of implying serialized artists aren’t putting in all their effort- I’m sure you didn't mean it that way but it just came off like that

    You’re telling us that saying the other version is not as beautiful as the other is inconsiderate but your comment still implies that the promo art is still better visually

    There’s nothing wrong with saying which art style you like better
    Everyone has their own opinion
    If they like the promo art better and think it’s visually more appealing thats fine- it doesn’t mean that the serialized ver. is bad— they just preferred the art style in the promo

    Obviously both the promo art and the serialized art is pretty
    Others just prefer one art style over the other that’s simply it- there’s nothing wrong with that

    If you eat the same food made by two different people and you say you think the other is tastier than the former is that rude? No— it’s just the one suited you tastes better

    Sorry that I went off on a tangent- hopefully this doesn’t come across as rude
    Obviously if people are being rude about the art style in the serialized ver. it’s uncalled for and they should stop that
    It’s just that I’ve never understood the whole “Oh they're both good it’s rude to say that the other is better than the former” idea

    Beauty is subjective- everyone has diff. tastes- there’s nothing rude about having your own opinion and liking something more over the other

    It shouldn’t be considered wrong to prefer something more-
    Obviously if someone went to the serialized ver. (Where it’s originally posted) and started talking about how the promo is better that’s rude and insensitive

    I personally like the promo art better but that doesn’t mean I dislike the serialized art—
    And it might not seem like it but always saying that they’re both just as good without any reasoning behind it can be pretty bad (not necessarily directed at you I’m just stating this)

    I’m not an artist- but I drew as a hobby
    There were times where I would show drawings and ask for my friends opinions and they would just say that they're both good

    While it was nice that they said that- they just felt like empty words because it’s not like they pin pointed anything they liked from the drawings itself

    Instead of feeling good about my drawings I felt bad about them because I wanted to make it better- know what the good points of my drawing were and what the bad points were

    Obviously I’m not asking people for in depth art advice since I’m just a casual drawer but it would be nice to know what people liked and what they think could be improved in a drawing

    Its good to say that they're both pretty but saying it without meaning is just as rude