Can you give me the link to the novel if you still have it, thank you!
So I'll now explain the "2nd arc" where I think the novel introduced ML(Crow), basically explains how they FL and Crow met and bounded, then goes on to explain Crows origins. (AGAIN THIS IS ALL MOST LIKELY NOT IN ORDER the novel it's self is like a puzzle piece where every detail CAN be important later on and it goes back and forth, I'm just saying the important stuff)
"2nd arc"
Crow meets FL for the first time at night when she was singing a song to her "baby" (trama) only ML and few people know the song. It's still unclear how FL learned the song. Btw they met in the TT where FL was locked up (literally) and the sister got preg. He showed up to her as a crow (I'll explain later) and if I remember correctly in the kingdom they are in crows are a sign of misfortune.(he can shapshift to a cat,crow,and his human self) FL was fascinated? cuz out of all the times she TT it was always the same people and the same cycle of dying, so she was surprised that she finally saw something new. Crow saw how miserable she looked and offered to grant her any wish. She only wished for her sister to be protected and safe. Unsatisfied with the answer Crow left, from then on he would visit FL learning more about her situation and just feeling completely baffled by how she was treated by the people around her. He would repeatedly ask FL about her wish, hoping that FL would wish for once about herself and not her sister, the more time he spent with her the more he was able to feel. Then once FL found out that her sister was preg with hubby (btw they married in this life too), she broke down, FL opened up to Crow and told him the truth that she's been doing back to the same miserable moment. She didn't tell him at first cuz of fear that it was unreasonable, crow didn't completely understand/believed her, FL's situation in a way reminded him of this own. Not being able to die and being miserable (I'll explain later) he blurted out "wow what sin did you do that was so bad to deserve this, it's like your living in your own personal hell for you and you alone" he didn't mean to say it to her, he was thinking this about himself and accidentally hurt her really bad, cuz for the first time FL asked for support and he said something cruel to FL. He left cuz he thought it was best for to both cool down, plus FL asked to be alone. The whole night be felt bad so the next morning he got FL favorite flowers wanting to apologise and Crow finally decided to take her away from this place even tho FL never wished it. Went in his human form with flowers ready to take her, he got disgusted at the fact the mistress (sister) answered the door and other things (that was the job of the wife) he was ready to take her by force if he had too. As they went to FL's prison room they found her dead hanged herself. Sister screamed and started bleeding, all servants were busy trying to save the baby that they ignored FL's body. Crow ignored everyone else but FL, took her body and started walking endlessly, he was torn blaming himself that she died. He walked endlessly with her corpse and talking to it. He started crying even tho he shouldn't be able to(I'll explain later) for the first time he resented god. Crow met "him" again. "He" gave crow a clue saying "do you believe in God" and hinting that "God made more then one world" so crow made some in-between world hoping magics to find FL and save her. His theory was that the reason FL always failed was because everyone & everything was the same but the people's personalities were always different, that's why she couldn't predict their movements. So he basically spent time looking for her but he would either find FL just about to die, or that FL doesn't know him, or a world without FL.
Okay that one was long ugh ngl I had to go back and re-read some of it. I forgot why FL says that her sister "saved her" in the past. Like sorry the sister tbh was irrelevant. I'll do the next few arc when I have time, if anyone asks for spoilers just send then this comment I took wayy too much time writing all this. I'll go the next one in a few hours :))
omgg thankyou for explaining hoping to see you write more cause i cbf reading the manga now HAHAHAH
This is gonna be my 3rd arc where I'm going to explain Crows origins, the "him" guy, and explain a few more things. In the novel it dedicated a long arc explaining first, crows origins and then tells how he met FL.(which I wrote about in my 2nd arc) since I am bad at explaining and i didn't want to be confusing, I first spoiled how they met instead of his origins (trying to keep a sorta clean timeline) I had to stop my "2nd arc" for the sake of my sleep and sanity there just so much things that happen and are all important.
3rd arc..it's gonna be long sorry :(
Crows real name is Kaliarya Ignis born in a time with magic(some people had it some didn't) mom was an ordinary noble, dad was POWERFUL magician. Political marriage but hinted that why loved each other. Mom died when crow was young, dad was distant with Crow. When 5, Crow's dad used him to cast the immortality spell, he fainted woke up with weird marks that eventually faded, last time he saw his dad. His dad left to do something left crow with "him"(he's basically Crows doctor the one I mentioned in arc 2) dad was showing his knight friend the his completed (forbidden btw) immortality spell cast on himself. But it backfires makes his body turn into ash and he disappeared. Knight delivers new that dad "died in action" later on crow meets knight again and finds out how dad died. Crow lives alone off dad inheritance, until he meets Emma. Emma is crows past lover, her & her mom moved to capital for money but mom died and she was left homeless, she she's from a place were there's unique songs only a few people know (hint song FL sang that crow remembered) and also believes that crows bring both good and bad luck(crows in this novel are extinct btw). Crow picks Emma up, they live together, go to school together, fall in love, they get married. He became a magician and she became a magic doll maker (important) As time pass Crow notice that he didn't age, he eventually found out about the immortality spell and dad's death. Although he was scared, at some point Emma and Crow talked about having kids but just like his dad parts of his body started falling off and turning to ash. Poor Emma was confused and traumatized has part of his body slowly fell off. He met the doctor that explains that he was already dead but somehow still alive, Crow left devastated. He was at home with emotional Emma as they talked out what they should do but unfortunately Crow's remaining body turned into dust and he disappeared in front of Emma. Somehow even tho his body was gone he was still alive, he saw how traumatized Emma was as he couldn't do anything. Crow teleported to the doctor, who could sends his magic and help develop a magic so that crow could be seen (ONLY to people who have magic, he can't touch,or be heard) took many years but finally he was able to appear in front of Emma. Emma screamed when she saw crow he was suppos to be dead to leave her alone, crushed Crow only watched as she was comforted by her new partner (Can't see crow) he still stayed around hoping that Emma would accept him, but she kept rejecting/ignoring Crow in denial. Sometimes scream for him to disappear. She moved out of her house determined to move forward in life. Crow learned that the doctor died and with regret spent his days wondering. As years passed less and less people could see him. He met Emma one last time as she was about to die of old age(she had some kids and moved forward). Emma talked to Crow about what black birds meant (story) A black bird appears at the window speaking and asking one question, answer correctly and your blessed otherwise it brings misfortune. Explains how to her ML was like her "black bird" that brought her happyness, she apologized and died. Poor crow was left alone and devastated. Sorry for the wait I had to write down what happened and re-read, after covering all the arcs I wanna reread the whole novel. I felt like it was getting too long so there will be a part 2 of arc 3. Explaining how ML got the name crow and how he was able to touch FL, see you in a bit ;)
WOWOW ty for explaining again HAHAH !!!
im too lazy to read da novel so thanks for explaining!!
THANK
Wow....thanks...... I was feeling kinda heavy reading the manga, and read some spoiler saying it just always gonna repeat the misery of FL so I kinda thinking of not rrading the novel coz if feels too heavy for me...
But reading your spoilers I feel kinda lighter, thanks
Thank you for the explanation. I hate tragedies but this makes me want to continue reading the manga. I'll wait for the part 2.
let me just say that i love you LIKE FRFR YOU TOOK THE TIME TO WRITE THIS ALL OUT- i'll for sure be taking the time to read the novel !!
Thank you for thisಥ‿ಥ I'm gonna reply just to see if you'll still continue it
ლ(´-`ლ)
Thank you guys and sorry ngl I've been lazy to write the next few arcs(￣∇￣")
I'm planning on uploading ALL arcs the next so you guys don't have to Wait in-between, so I do it all at once and don't get as lazy. I'll try to do all the test this week(๑•ㅂ•)و✧
Thank you so much ヾ(☆▽☆)
Thaaaanks your long ass spoilers are amazing (≧∀≦)
Commenting so I can read it when you’re done! Thank you so much for the summaries
They both have such sad pasts
Thank you for allt the spoilers, I'm waiting for the tea when the bastard husband and bitch sister gets what they deserved!! I really hope they will!
Thank you so much for the spoilers! I’m glad that the novel has a bittersweet ending rather than an endless loop of pain, because Emma was able to be happy and see Crow for one last time! I don’t think I will read the novel since my eyes will be swollen from crying too much, but now I’m fascinated with the story!
OMG thank you ヾ(☆▽☆)
I'm gonna spoil basically the whole novel, it's been like a year since I read the novel and fell in love with the novel and words that just suck you in and makes you cry. I hate seeing or reading sad stuff but this was just too good to pass. It's not a shitty story guys just because of some bad spoilers out there.(im going to go by arcs heres the first, most likely not in order after all it's been like a year) Even if I spoil it you should read it my words won't make you cry and feel like the novel did.
...1st arc
So the first arc is basically specific on the FL's first few time travels (I'ma call them that instead of reincarnation TT for short) the first 4 TT tells how the FL basically tries to get away from the hell she lives in, so it only sets up the plot doesn't really move it, after these 4 specific TT FL explains that everything else is a blur. On later blurred TT's she slowly discovers the secrets of her "family". On her first TT as seen, she lives gets married, resents her sister, her fiance (call him hubby cuz he goes from fiance to husband alot) resents FL for being mean to her only weak sister, sister dies, hubby takes her to prison cuz he thinks it's her, she gets abandon, she dies. On her 2nd TT she feels like it's her fault that she felt happy when her sister dies so she sets a plan so that her sister is able to replace her, she makes plans to run away. She thought she had feeling for her knight and considered eloping together but she didn't, FL didn't want to cause him pain (on a past TT she did elopped with him cuz she thought she liked him, but they got caught by hubby's mom. The knight died, she got jailed and blamed by knights ex-fiance. Ex-fiance blamed FL for the fact that the knight took pity on FL and picked FL over his own fiance and died) she decided to run away alone this time. FL spent alot of time teacher her sister to be able to replace her, so Hubby started liking her? a bit more. But as she ran away she got betrayed by the traffickers and they made her a prostitute. (Bear with me I don't remember the timeline that well) she spent her days with a broken body getting weaker and weaker, with Crow's help (ML) her knight and sister found her on her death bed both were really happy to see her except hubby. Sister and hubby got married cuz FL left(both families WANTED A MARRIAGE), they had some kids. Hubby said how betrayed he felt that FL left. Her Knight abandon everything else and spent his whole life trying to find FL, he let himself go and looked beat. Both sister and knight cried as she passed away. On this TT she prevents the the bandits from liking the sister and lives her life as the perfect sister and wife. She gets married to hubby, they decided to have a child out of obligation. Her sister keeps on getting sicker and sicker. Hubby spends alot of time with sick sister alone (barely home Smh). They visit her together as she was weak enough to die, sister confess that she loves fiance, they argue? Sister cries, hubby blames FL, hubby prevents FL and sister from meeting cuz he doesn't trust her, FL about to give birth but hubby doesn't come home alot cuz he's with sister, FL give birth early cuz of stress,she chooses her child's life over hers and gives birth with only the doctor by her side, she dies. On the TT that's right after the one where she gives birth, she breaks down from the trama, her parents lock her up she's treated as an insane person and is put on house arrest, she meets Crow(ML) in this TT (I'll explain Crow and meeting in 2nd arc) her sister somehow became preg and is mistress. She died triggered by something Crow said (not intentionally) she committed suicide and died. Finally done with first arc sorry if I got the timeline not exactly in the same order but I am mentioning everything important, it takes time to write everything down so please be patient. I'll write the rest in later :))
https://www.novelupdates.com/series/my-fiance-is-in-love-with-my-little-sister/