Shounen Ai vs. Yaoi

Darkness_Queen June 22, 2020 6:57 am

To all you people who like BL, do you prefer stories without R18/smutty scenes, or stories with them?

I personally prefer shounen ai, though I don't mind the sex scenes.

Responses
    astralsensei June 22, 2020 7:04 am

    Uh depends on the vibe. Usually cross-genres like yaoi and sci-fi don’t mix well with me so I prefer them to be strictly romance or the latter. I wouldn’t complain if I see some sexy banging though.

    PearlySkies June 22, 2020 7:14 am

    I’m about the same. A story that completely revolves around the characters having sex tends to get boring for me pretty quickly so I try to find very plot heavy stories. Most plot heavy stories tend to be shounen ai so I usually end up looking on those tags to find something worth reading. Not saying I hate sex/smut scenes but they can get really repetitive if the author isn’t...great at them. It’s pretty funny though cuz when I first started reading BL I almost exclusively read smut, but as I’ve gone further into the genre I’ve been able to drift away from that.

    JMB June 22, 2020 7:37 am

    it all depends on the story tbh, i've read both extremes and have liked them. I'm a huge fan of the K-sensei series which is mostly smut, but also have enjoyed stories where there are no sex scenes at all (cherry blossoms before they started getting intimate). I usually prefer there to be some r-18 scenes, though, and find myself wishing there were some after reading a shounen ai.

    fairybloss June 22, 2020 7:42 am

    i like both, it depends what mood i'm in. although a lot of the times i fancy more fluffy and heart-clenching-bc-of-how-cute-and-fluffy-it-is with no smut type mangas/manhuas bc there's not a lot of them.

    WoeyLeaf June 22, 2020 8:46 am

    I like a little bit of it in the end as long as it's mostly censored and both of them are in love AND contains no weird kinks.

    anonymous June 22, 2020 8:48 am

    im horny asf I come for the rates r and 18+ sex scenes but sometimes I read shounen ai and some are quite good

    thatonewe_eb June 22, 2020 12:54 pm

    i'm mostly a yaoi kinda guy because i'm all about the darkness and twisted characters. Shounen ai is more fluffy and cute and is not as messed up as some yaoi . I do sometimes read shounen ai if it's angsty or sad like never understand. You won't really find shounen ai like killing stalking, obey me , painter of the night or an easy target which are some of my favourites and very messed up.