PS to the 4 (and counting in the future who will dislike this), if the roles were reversed i.e MC is a 40 year old male, I wonder if you will still think the same.
Everyone has their own opinions, but thats just her mental age. Then, in that case, isnt every reincarnation manga ever made gross? Regardless of the age they died at, they are at least 16-40 years older than the one they end up with XD #JustLogic
yes you are right about some reincarnated/isekai MCs being older than their physical age. But most of their 'previous bodies' are either teens or young adults, and when they are reincarnated they are mostly reincarnated into bodies which are more or less the same age and also surrounded by ppl who are the same age. (Yes, I know there is also WMMAP and Lady baby) What i cannot stand about this manga is the 'relatable' aspect. How is a 40 year old relevant in an early teen context? The mindset and behaviour is totally different, and for the MC to still act like a pre-pubescent teen 'loving for the first time' is bizarre to me imo.
The ones you mentioned are the cross overs, I meant reincarnations. When they are reborn literally as babies. Cross overs (body take overs) are a bit different. I do understand where your argument is coming from though, but I'm just saying the rest of those ''reincarnation'', and I do not mean cross over / take over body, are the same in a way. Except here the gap is even larger, and they usually make the MC 'single' until like 35 cuz she was busy with work etc. Even so, the difference here, would probably be that she did have a child. But like, in a way it is her first time falling in love in 'this life' although I don't understand how that thing ''falling in love'' works anyway. BUT, maybe she had married someone she thought she loved but she has never really been able to feel love. I mean, idk where she is from I forgot, but in asia many young women marry due to pressure of other people, family, coworkers, wishing to have a more stable financial life etc. It wasn't really explained, and her husband wasn't even mentioned once. It was either overlooked or intended. I too, actually don't think it's appropriate that they make it look like she is an innocent little girl (when 40 inside), but I hope there that usual plot - " My daughter is actually the daughter of my sister, since her parents (sister and husband) died in an accident and no one wanted to take them in I have decided to raise her by myself. " But I highly doubt the plot will go like that. :P So like, I'm just reading for whatever happens I don't even care lol. It's fiction anyway
Well yeah I agree with you that its fiction, I guess this manga overall just doesnt appeal to me. Similarly when I read Usagi Drop. to each their own.
This is just getting out of hand lmao. The MC is a 40 YEAR OLD WOMAN WITH A GROWN ASS DAUGHTER. And I assume in the future chpts there will be some romance going on with her and the prince? That to me..is plain gross. I'm dropping this.