stupid reasoning

mia uwuchima June 5, 2020 9:20 pm

seriously? you don't want ur family to be TOO powerful?? just overthrow the government, i stg not worth the read

Responses
    NoisyShadow June 5, 2020 9:35 pm

    That was addressed, they could try, but realistically they'd be betrayed and abandoned by allies. Once they failed their family would be executed, as traitors are.
    Powerful enough to be a threat, but not powerful enough to take on the royals, government, army and fellow nobles with few if any allies. She's just trying to keep her family alive and get the target off their backs. Other options could be available to reduce their power and influence, but she's just following the script she knows.

    bluekey June 5, 2020 9:45 pm

    honestly the author doesn't understand old medieval age politic or she is just playing dumb
    in most cases for such a family there is only one choice:
    -having them marry the royal family (so they can back you up financially )
    if the family does have only daughter it's easy as taking candy from a baby to just let someone from the royal family marry a daughter and take over as ruler for the estate
    because honestly they aren't a threat unless they try to rise their military strength

    Kazenami June 6, 2020 12:44 pm

    From what I know, a noble family will truly be a threat to the royal if they have a powerful military strength. I honestly thought there are some kind of reasonable reason but what? It's just that? I mean... There are a lot of way to settle that.

    mia uwuchima June 6, 2020 3:44 pm
    From what I know, a noble family will truly be a threat to the royal if they have a powerful military strength. I honestly thought there are some kind of reasonable reason but what? It's just that? I mean... Th... Kazenami

    yeah! exactly that's what i meant, it's just horrible reasoning overall, she's basically saying, i'll have my family become broke because we have to much money

    bananice June 6, 2020 4:52 pm
    honestly the author doesn't understand old medieval age politic or she is just playing dumbin most cases for such a family there is only one choice: -having them marry the royal family (so they can back you up ... bluekey

    Ikr it doesnt make sense at all. If her house is really that powerful as described in the story, the royal family would definitely comes to engage the crown prince with her. Even if her father lets her lives a carefree life, if a royal orders him to marry his daughter, he's bound to agree.

    mia uwuchima June 6, 2020 5:10 pm
    Ikr it doesnt make sense at all. If her house is really that powerful as described in the story, the royal family would definitely comes to engage the crown prince with her. Even if her father lets her lives a ... bananice

    ikr! she's seriously so dumb

    agathe June 12, 2020 10:06 pm

    Really ? But historically she makes sense, just like generals get broken or murdered in chinese novel when the official power feels threatened, if her family has to many asets, and influence, they'll be tripped, sooner or later.
    she happens to know it will happen in her generation because of the game, so she aims at a lesser evil, or do uou believe having few predictions of the future necessarily opens the way to better solutions ? How could she possibly have that much influence in just one year ?

    Kazenami June 13, 2020 6:06 am
    Really ? But historically she makes sense, just like generals get broken or murdered in chinese novel when the official power feels threatened, if her family has to many asets, and influence, they'll be tripped... agathe

    First, saying that his father is easily trust people is already doesn't make sense. I mean, how can someone like that able to raise that high?
    Second, she have one year right? I able to teach my parents about scam in less than one hour. So, can't she teach her father not to trust people easily in one year?
    Next, you said "generals" get broken or murdered in chinese novel right? As we already said, "generals" mean involved in military. Royal see threat if a fam have a big military influence.
    And If I were the royal, I will not remove someone who have a big money and instead marry my children to that house so I will gain more.