I Hate Jeanette so fucking much like shes actually so dumb to the point that she doesn’t...

actually... THAT MIGHT ACTUALLY WORK

Agreed

I honestly want that too but like, way more tragic. Can you imagine? Athy is fed up with being always the last choice for three whole lives, decides that it's not worth any of her time anymore because she is always hurting no matter what. She asks Lucas to bring her far away, this time forever, and since he loves her and is tired of her crying over the stupid emperor, he manipulates her memories so she knows that she is trasmigrated but she doesn't remember the 10 years she spent with Claude. She starts living with him far away and she becomes a magician just like him.
A few years later Lucas and Athy (who doesn't remember anything) return to Obelia and Lucas hits Claude, who kept on calling Jeannette because of his headache, with the branch so he remembers everything from start to finish (even Lovely Princess time line). He kneels in front of Athy and beg for forgiveness but Athy doesn't even remember him and sees him as the pathetic monster who just killed LP! Athy favoring Jeannette. So Claude, who is now mad with rage just send away (or kill since we know he is able to) forever the whole Alpheus family and Jeannette, finally telling everyone that he is not her father

Wait... Is that a spoiler? Or you just made that up?

Haha it's not a spoiler. It's how I wish this story would go

Janette is a child she doesnt know what's is right from wrong ..Athy on the other hand is a grown as adult she knows what she is doing. Clearly your protecting a child with a mentality of an adult. Janette knows she has a family but she can also clearly see that she does not fit in there love. So far I still like jannette and I hope she gets a happy ending too .. when she told athy that she loves her like a sister and athy did not replied but dogged it broke my heart because jannette really meant that

Sorry! Haha! I misunderstood

FUCKING PERIODT