They are both illegal, but I think there's been cases in the past with other webtoons where people got in trouble for uploading translations with licensed titles. If you think about it if people uploaded translations when the official english chapter has not even been released yet, there will be even LESS people buying the official release.
Also another thing- if someone is uploading translated chapters then the person uploading and buying the official english chapters will stop uploading them. What happens when the translator eventually drops this project or gets too busy? No one will be uploading the chapters anymore. Just be patient.
Nope. I (and a few other people) pay for all chapters on the legal site (Tappytoon) so your broke ass can read it for free here. Uploading chapters that aren't even released yet is just fucking rude toward people like me. (I'm here because Tappytoon doesn't have a comment section BTW)
Couldn't have said it better myself. Not to mention how rude it is to the author and the official english release platform. These "broke ass" people are on the fast track to ruining it for the rest of us, when authors decide official english trans is a waste of time since impatient pricks are half-assing their own versions
Hm. I am sorry but i am very suspicious with declarations like yours. I mean there are many sites that do not upload mangas and you can have a conversation with others about it and no advertising. What are you doing here? Also, how did you read some of the work you have in your profile that there is no official translation? Maybe there is a logical answer to all these (cant say no) but my broke ass is always wondering.
Still. It's only logical and fair that people who pays for it could read it before us. And lots of people, after being able to read it for free and faster than the licensed, won't pay for the official chapters that would be releases later. (That would frankly bé m'y case. It's sas but the easy way...) That would just lead to the author's salary dropping and not being able to continue the story. I already heard of authors dropping series because of that.
My broke ass is really thankful for all of you who actually pay for the webtoons and upload them here! So thank you ╮(￣▽￣)╭
Yes you are right. I read things here BECAUSE they don't have an official translations. But you bet when they do I will be there paying, so the authors can have a living. My problem is when people don't have a sense of boundary. Just don't fucking fan translate series that have an official release. That's it. Do you want my bank transaction confirmations of what I pay monthly to Lezhin, Tappytoon and Tapas? :-)
YEP
I was really broke too one too, so I know what's it like. That's why I'm trying to buy everything so the karma is balanced out, haha. the problem is when people who don't pay get fucking rude about it, like WHAT
yes, thank you. At least can we have the reward for paying that we can read it first???
I am just suspicious by comments like that here, but you said that you do read for free other stories so i get it. I have read bs comments though stating they never read a manga for free and the comment is on mangago....
Ps: i dont need the transaction, and please dont be eager to share your bank details :p
https://www.amazon.com/Were-All-Porn-Stars-Cybersecurity-ebook/dp/B078GSTDYT
Dude I was just stating my opinion.
Btw I am not broke. It's just that in my country tappytoon and all the other websites are not available. Otherwise I would have bought it long ago.(●￣(ｴ)￣●)
Totally with you.
Ignore what the people say. They be like I want updates but paid translations which are still illegal. And here they are condemning your hard work. Ignorant contradictory people