I'm just confused. So her brother suddenly now shows up and declares to save her... but wh...

Haru October 20, 2019 7:54 pm

I'm just confused. So her brother suddenly now shows up and declares to save her... but what about her previous life? Her brother never bothered to show up.... This feels a bit poor in terms of writing...

Responses
    dagrandesibuna October 20, 2019 8:40 pm

    If you notice, he was going to the war in the south and not returning home. He felt he needed to win that war to gain "enough strength". Then Ian pointed out there was a higher chance for him to die than to win, so my guess is he actually died in his previous life before getting the chance to help Iris. Since Iris is changing the story along the way, that letter asking him to go back might also be product of that. It would mean that letter didn't arrive before, not only that, but Ian himself didn't interact with Iris in his past life either. That's another important story point, since Iris has been actively looking for Ian's, Danny's and the other two characters (yet to be introduced) help in order to change her destiny. It might all be mounting out to that, his brother is finally going home to her after she by herself changed her destiny.

    Haru October 21, 2019 2:17 am
    If you notice, he was going to the war in the south and not returning home. He felt he needed to win that war to gain "enough strength". Then Ian pointed out there was a higher chance for him to die than to win... dagrandesibuna

    Ah, makes sense. Ok, I understand it better now. Thank you. (●'◡'●)ノ

    dagrandesibuna October 21, 2019 3:32 am
    Ah, makes sense. Ok, I understand it better now. Thank you. (●'◡'●)ノ Haru

    No problem! I might be wrong of course but that's what I got from it and thought it made sense somehow, I'm glad if I helped even a little (=・ω・=)

    MiLady1997 October 21, 2019 1:12 pm
    If you notice, he was going to the war in the south and not returning home. He felt he needed to win that war to gain "enough strength". Then Ian pointed out there was a higher chance for him to die than to win... dagrandesibuna

    Is this from the novel?
    I'm more convinced that the previous Iris died before he could have the strength to help her. I thought the letter was written by the head maid informing the brother that Iris is in danger?

    dagrandesibuna October 21, 2019 3:20 pm
    Is this from the novel? I'm more convinced that the previous Iris died before he could have the strength to help her. I thought the letter was written by the head maid informing the brother that Iris is in dang... MiLady1997

    No, I haven't read the novel. And yes indeed it's as you said, she died before he could help her or in exchange he died before he could help her. Either way a death was involved. The thing about the letter is important, because then that made the connection for him to return home instead of 'becoming stronger' at this point in the timeline. He had no plans to return at the moment, but that letter made him go back. So you could say the letter, even if it wasn't sent by Iris, actually changed the storyline again. And the letter was sent in order to help her, which means indirectly Iris is the one that changed the story itself. At least that's how I see it!

    If anyone's read the novel I might be wrong of course, but that's how I see it!

    luna November 11, 2019 2:39 am
    No, I haven't read the novel. And yes indeed it's as you said, she died before he could help her or in exchange he died before he could help her. Either way a death was involved. The thing about the letter is i... dagrandesibuna

    This actually makes a lot of sense, thanks kind stranger

    dagrandesibuna November 11, 2019 7:20 pm
    This actually makes a lot of sense, thanks kind stranger luna

    No problem, I'm happy if I was able to help by sharing my thoughts or own opinions :)