Um... no? Its a trope, not a cliche...? And it's actually the whole point of this story. If you want the story to not make sense that's your prerogative but don't assume others want the same thing. Okay?
To say that what you call a "trope" is the whole point fo the story is just sad. You do agree that it's a recurring unoriginal plot yet you're okay with the story revolving around it...
And what's with "If you want the story to not make sense that's your prerogative" ?? Which part of my comment said that? So not settling for a repetitive plot and wanting originality is equivalent to me "not wanting this to make sense"? What's with that logic!
Here, let me put it to you in a way that's easy for you to grasp: I want the story to make sense but with original not so cliché plot. I hope you got that
I hate that they pulled the memory loss bullshit. You know a story is too cliché when that happens