ok i´m confused. it´s tagged as shounen ai but at the start it say´s ´no bl´?

Kyoko_Nox July 10, 2017 5:14 am

ok i´m confused.
it´s tagged as shounen ai but at the start it say´s ´no bl´?

Responses
    Anonymous July 10, 2017 8:38 am

    It's a red herring. Author wants to just write a cute love story without labels. Should not be tagged shounen ai (that doesn't even exist in Japanese...see how it says BL everywhere lol?)

    Kyoko_Nox July 10, 2017 11:50 am
    It's a red herring. Author wants to just write a cute love story without labels. Should not be tagged shounen ai (that doesn't even exist in Japanese...see how it says BL everywhere lol?) @Anonymous

    why does shounen i not exist in Japan? don´t get it

    Kazure July 10, 2017 1:30 pm
    It's a red herring. Author wants to just write a cute love story without labels. Should not be tagged shounen ai (that doesn't even exist in Japanese...see how it says BL everywhere lol?) @Anonymous

    DUDE. Shounen Ai exists in Japanese. BL is short for ''Boys Love''. Shounen means ''boy'' in Japanese while Ai means ''love''. Shounen Ai and BL are literally one and the same. What even.

    Kazure July 10, 2017 1:46 pm

    @kyoko it says no bl because it won't explicitly show sexual/intimate scenes that you commonly see in yaoi

    Kyoko_Nox July 10, 2017 2:09 pm

    @kazure: si=bl that´s what i thought too ^^
    and well yes. since it´s shounen ai of Course there would be no sex.
    because then it would be yaoi ^^

    Kazure July 10, 2017 3:16 pm
    @kazure: si=bl that´s what i thought too ^^ and well yes. since it´s shounen ai of Course there would be no sex. because then it would be yaoi ^^ Kyoko_Nox

    yup you are correct, this anon person made me so confused

    Siti July 12, 2017 11:02 am
    DUDE. Shounen Ai exists in Japanese. BL is short for ''Boys Love''. Shounen means ''boy'' in Japanese while Ai means ''love''. Shounen Ai and BL are literally one and the same. What even. Kazure

    Actually no,in Japan they do not call it shounen ai or yaoi,they call it BL. Shonen ai and yaoi is westerners terms,they dont exist in japan ^^

    Kazure July 12, 2017 2:25 pm
    Actually no,in Japan they do not call it shounen ai or yaoi,they call it BL. Shonen ai and yaoi is westerners terms,they dont exist in japan ^^ Siti

    Yes, Japanese mainly call mangas with male on male relationships as BL. No, Shounen Ai and Yaoi are not western terms. Shounen-ai itself is a japanese word and was created by Japanese women authors in early 1970's to depict beautiful boys in love. YAOI on the other hand is a Japanese acronym (YAma nashi, Ochi nashi, Imi nashi) which translates to "no climax, no point, no meaning". In Japanese speech and writing, YAOI is a slang term used to refer to stories that focus on homosexual relationships between men that involve graphic sex with little to no plot (hence the meaning "no climax, no point, no meaning").

    How did you come to the conclusion that these terms do not exist in Japan? They are literally Japanese words.

    Anonymous July 12, 2017 2:27 pm

    i didnt know yaoi was actually an acronym. huh. the more you know. thanks for the knowledge good sir

    Kazure July 12, 2017 2:28 pm
    i didnt know yaoi was actually an acronym. huh. the more you know. thanks for the knowledge good sir @Anonymous

    haha im actually a girl but no problem

    Kyoko_Nox July 12, 2017 5:18 pm

    in other words Japan prefers to use foreign words and the foreigners prefer to use japanese words. why am i not surprised?! ^^

    Siti July 12, 2017 9:32 pm
    Yes, Japanese mainly call mangas with male on male relationships as BL. No, Shounen Ai and Yaoi are not western terms. Shounen-ai itself is a japanese word and was created by Japanese women authors in early 197... Kazure

    Uh,what i mean do not exist was they dont use this term like what majority us foreigners know n using it as in that yaoi is hardcore n shonen ai is softcore. They call it bl for a long time now,yes those two term are originally from japan,but like i said,they have different meaning from what westerners using ^^

    Kazure July 13, 2017 4:30 am
    Uh,what i mean do not exist was they dont use this term like what majority us foreigners know n using it as in that yaoi is hardcore n shonen ai is softcore. They call it bl for a long time now,yes those two te... Siti

    Oh okay yeah, I get your point now :) The way you constructed your sentence earlier kinda confused me