
She pretty much straight up told him she did it cause she wanted to die and told him off, criticized him and kinda suggested that him confessing to her so suddenly is kinda bullshit, like kinda pointed out his inconsistency with it. Like she didn’t accept his feelings, she was very cold and criticized him, def didn’t try to comfort him or be considerate like “you shouldn’t abandon your morals for me”. As far as I remember btw, read it a while ago, but u should def read it too, it was very satisfying. I do definitely remember her being ice cold tho

I still think his feelings are nonsense tho Just like Penelope in the novel did. Like, he barely spent any time with her, he doesn’t know her well and he never shown interest. He’s apparently someone with very strong values and out of nowhere he suddenly loves her so much he’s willing to abandon everything he worked for and his own values? Idk, to me that’s just way too random and weird. Seems inconsistent with his character and kinda weird writing

well, that's true, especially in manhwa... I personally realy like him, he's the most normal of the options, but it is a fact that his feelings are out of nowhere... And about her being nicer and the whole discussion... from what I remember, this conversation went pretty similar, and all this 'bullshit things' was just in Penelope's head... of course if I remember corectlly

He is normal, but he simply has too little interaction with her for his feelings and that situation to make sense.
But yeah from I remember she was much colder to him in the novel than here, I think there’s a big difference. However, I also read that a while ago so I can be wrong, but I specifically remember cause I was surprised how coldly she treated him when I thought he didn’t really do much to her to act that way.

well if you think of it thoroughly, her behawior isn't exactly out of nowher... she is simply sick of ewerythink and eweryone, and then nowone know from where Winter and his like he say love, when she know it isn't even love, and all his talk about that bi*h and how angelick she is... really if I was in her place, I would punch him... propably.
She was much nicer to Vinter than in the novel honestly