i would read tf outta that fanfic honestly ANYTHING is better than mingwa's plot
I might actually do it in the future then. Given so many great examples out there, I at least know what NOT to do when I write it.
This is honesty so disrespectful to the author. Oh my god this is so basic, might as well get into it.
Why do you people keep reading this if you don't like it? Just stop. It's that simple.
Reading this and complaining is pretty bipolar and shows that you have TOO much time on your hands.
If you don't fw the author then save some of your braincells. I think you have a very limited amount of braincells, so save them. Yapping about how "ANYTHINH is better than mingwa's plot" is rich coming from a person who can't achieve 0.5% of the things mingwa's achieved. Art of this quality doesn't grow on trees.
There is nothing disrespectful about having a better idea for a plot that has alot of issues. And even less so making a fanfic about it. Even official authors do this (of other official authors or even their OWN works). So I have no idea how you come up with that nonsense.
Calling people stupid simply because they don't praise something you like to the heavens IS however disrespectful. Very much so actually. :)
Please stop using words that you don't know how to use correctly. Bi-polar has a set meaning, which does not apply to any of this.
Also: "Yapping about how "ANYTHINH is better than mingwa's plot" is rich coming from a person who can't achieve 0.5% of the things mingwa's achieved. Art of this quality doesn't grow on trees."
Is probably the dumbest thing you could possibly say. Especially when the writing of the story and the art have nothing to do with one another in the end of judging a story as a whole.
Saying a comic is good and cannot be written better just because the art is top tier is a really stupid take and shows you do not understand what skills are required for success or for voicing critique or critique-driven opinions.
There are dozens of people out there with better stories than Mingwa, yet because their art sucks nobody cares about their works. Art and writing are two completely different subjects.
If you think a comic is perfect just because of good art, you probably shouldn't judge people who actually consider the WRITING of the story. The entire community is well aware of how many good artists make comics with absolutely ass plotlines. Especially webtoon smut comics.
And no, just because people do not like a story doesn't mean they automatically need to stop reading. Not everybody needs to be that immature. There are people capable of reading/watching something they do not 100%ly agree with and NOT get their panties in a twist like a toddler not getting a cookie.
And I think I made it quite clear that I do not hate the story entirely, I doubt half the readers who dislike it hate the story fully, it's just making alot of obnoxious mistakes all the time instead of making progress. And that is something NOBODY is free of. Not the writer of Bleach, not Mingwa, not the writers of Lord of the Rings. MANY people with success make mistakes and many people without success can have good or better ideas for some scenarios. Even if you do not like that fact. Being an official figure means nothing, because some people simply do not persue the same career.
You writing a whole ass essay shows that you do have your panties in a twist, but whatever floats your boat man. It's not like I don't read fanfics, cause I do. I've read countless Jinx fanfics as well. But those authors always mentioned a sentence 'No disrespect to the original author'. You can dislike or not agree on a story without being disrespectful to the original author.
Plus, I wasn't replying to you, I was replying to the other person who I thought was disrespectful to mingwa
Ah, so you're one of those who thinks a detailed explaination is someone being upset. How very mature, adult and civilized of you.
You talking about being respectful is honestly ironic when you cannot abide by your own rules after reading a sentence that boils down to "I would read a fanfic with a better plot than this story actually has.".
The writing is mediocre at best, it's only the art that saves this story from being disliked.
I replied because my comment is essentially indicating the same opinion, just with more words and details. Mentioning positive and negative things alike.
If you don't want lengthy replies, then maybe you shouldn't start arguements. Especially not ones in which you post strange, rude or unapplicable things. They WILL be adressed by people who can actually focus on a discussion more than 10 seconds.
You have TOO much time in your hands. Others might not.
Reading one single chapter of any comic on this website takes MUCH longer than reading multiple of my posts.
If you have the attention span of a goldfish, that's not other people's problem. It's a you-problem. Especially if this is your response to anything after YOU started this arguement.
Just stop commenting and complaining if you don't want a conversation. Simple as that.
i don't think you understand what site you're on, or what anyone is saying. you don't have any right to stick a definition on anyone because you're oh so certain that you're more nuanced or respectful than others. it's very easy to type a comment that defends your point with half-assed insults. separating art from plot is very easy, it's kind of amusing that you use the terms so interchangeably. if you had used YOUR braincells to genuinely analyze the plot from an artistic view along with basic criteria of quality plot continuity and pacing, im sure you would've realized that this story is literally hanging on by a thread. though, that might be hard to do since you seem to have difficulty looking past the outer shell, the visual.
about the weird pedestal you just put mingwa on, i think you should solve that with yourself, man. belittling random people, that you know literally nothing about their lives whatsoever, on an anonymous webtoon reading site, is fucking hilarious and maybe a bit hysteric. i haven't even seen your overly defensive replies because i have better things to do, and don't 'have too much time on my hands'. have a lovely, and if possible, internet-shame free day.
wow, i think *you* might have too much time on your hands. go read a creative writing book about plot-building, pacing, reader retention and dynamic story-telling instead. i know it's easy to forget since, yknow, it's *the internet*, but people don't throw around baseless shit most of the time.
it's also pretty funny that you equate a genuine issue with the artistic and practical value of a story with not 'fucking with' the author. i don't know who mingwa is. therefore, i didn't comment on them, but their writing. unlike you, who feels adequate to call a random user 'bipolar' with 'limited braincells' just because you didn't use YOUR (presumably) definitely huge amount of braincells to think of asking them to explain their opinion. you know, having a humane conversation.
you should also do something about the pedestal you put your views on. you could've followed your own advice and just scrolled instead of typing out a paragraph. have a great day and i hope you learn how to separate different forms of art from each other in the foreseeable future.
Just was reminded I had to catch up on chapters here so lemme just say this:
It's getting a bit on my nerves to see JJs character jump from those hint-type denial moments in which it SEEMS like he realized his feelings for Dan back to him beign a total fuckwit that's not aware of basic human emotions like NOT finding it pleasant to get screwed by someone that has treated you like dogshit.
I wish the author would finally PICK something to go with.
I was also hoping we FINALLY get the start of JJs character developement in chapter 64, because Dan's words as he left and JJs expressions seemed to indicate that Dan's words had quite the heavy hit to them. But then chapter 65 starts and POOF, nothing at all settled into his dumbfuckerish head and he's back to being the usual jackass.
I'm tired of these things. So tired.
At this point I'm honestly contemplating writing up a fanfiction that does a better job than this. Just to get some sorta satisfactory developements. ╥﹏╥
The only thing that makes me truly happy is seeing Dan actually be done with JJs shit. That's a really great developement and I hope it's not magically undone by Granny leaving the cast and JJs patting his head for a minute. (I swear I will punch a european wall if this happens.)