I don't really understand what's the problem... why should the author be upset if the tran...

lemon May 15, 2017 2:27 pm

I don't really understand what's the problem... why should the author be upset if the translator is only translating the free chapters?

Responses
    Anonymous May 15, 2017 2:35 pm

    me neither... I don't understand what happened o.O

    moonlight May 15, 2017 4:17 pm
    me neither... I don't understand what happened o.O @Anonymous

    Free chapters still generate revenues through views on the Comica website.

    lemon May 15, 2017 4:42 pm
    Free chapters still generate revenues through views on the Comica website. @moonlight

    yes I know that, but thanks to the translations people become curious about what happens the next and then go to see the raws... I don't think anyone that don't speak korean would go to see them if it wasn't for who translated that in english... It's not like what happens with lezhin, in which translations (if there is an official one) damage the artist since people don't buy coins... ._.

    (wooo my english is really really bad sorry!( ̄∇ ̄") )

    Anonymous May 15, 2017 5:37 pm

    But all the chapters are free..
    You just need to wait for it to unlock by itself.
    So of course the author didn't want people to do the translations and post it somewhere else.

    shemi May 15, 2017 6:10 pm
    But all the chapters are free..You just need to wait for it to unlock by itself.So of course the author didn't want people to do the translations and post it somewhere else. @Anonymous

    You made no sense. Why would the author not want the translated chapters to be posted somewhere else? The translated chapters give her more views, because from those people come to see the raws. And they are free anyways, so why?
    I mean, if there were no English translation, the views would be limited to only Indonesia and Korea. But now people come to the official site to look at the authors work, people from all around the world! People from other continents like Europe, America, Australia. Heck, even from small countries like Lithania (me). Its beneficial to everyone!

    Anonymous May 15, 2017 6:52 pm
    You made no sense. Why would the author not want the translated chapters to be posted somewhere else? The translated chapters give her more views, because from those people come to see the raws. And they are fr... shemi

    If the author want it to be posted then they shouldn't have mention about illegal uploads..
    Go and check the author twitter so you'll know..
    And if u really appreciate the author u shouldn't have said that..
    Because ppl eventually shared it on social media like twitter, instagram and else..
    So there's no excuse about it.. illegal will always stay illegal.
    And something like that really discourage the author.

    lemon May 15, 2017 7:51 pm
    If the author want it to be posted then they shouldn't have mention about illegal uploads..Go and check the author twitter so you'll know..And if u really appreciate the author u shouldn't have said that..Becau... @Anonymous

    that's exactly what I don't understand... in which way it would damage the author? It made the comic known in a lot of coutryes= a loooot of views that if it wasn't translated wouldn't have existed. It would be right saying that it damages the author if the translator posted chapters that weren't unlocked yet. but that's not the case ._. It's a completely different situation from what happened with lezhin.... there might be some other reasons that we don't know.. ┑( ̄Д  ̄)┍

    Sery May 15, 2017 8:21 pm
    that's exactly what I don't understand... in which way it would damage the author? It made the comic known in a lot of coutryes= a loooot of views that if it wasn't translated wouldn't have existed. It would be... lemon

    The only reason I can think of is that comica (the site 'fools' comes from) were planning to release an official English site, so that's why they don't want illegal translations to ruin the release because people might not read it because they had already read the chapters before from these translations. Or it might be they don't like aggregate sites benefiting from ad revenue? Either way, it is known that some authors will actually give permission to translate free to view webtoons or they will turn a blink eye to illegal translations. So it really depends on how authors feel about fan translations as well as the company their webtoon is published in.

    Sery May 15, 2017 9:17 pm
    The only reason I can think of is that comica (the site 'fools' comes from) were planning to release an official English site, so that's why they don't want illegal translations to ruin the release because peop... Sery

    *blind

    Anonymous May 16, 2017 1:11 am
    If the author want it to be posted then they shouldn't have mention about illegal uploads..Go and check the author twitter so you'll know..And if u really appreciate the author u shouldn't have said that..Becau... @Anonymous

    "Illegal will always stay illegal." Sorry to break it to you but laws change everyday, of course i am not talking just about copyright laws specifically but all laws in general. Quick history lesson: In america in the early 1900's liquor was LEGAL and then in 1920 the sell, production, and consumption of alcohol was made ILLEGAL until 1933 and it was legal again. See laws change!

    Anonymous May 16, 2017 1:29 am
    The only reason I can think of is that comica (the site 'fools' comes from) were planning to release an official English site, so that's why they don't want illegal translations to ruin the release because peop... Sery

    I think mangago and other aggregated sites profiting off of this series is right on the money. People are getting paid off of their hard work and they aren't, it's plain and simple.

    lemon May 16, 2017 12:42 pm
    I think mangago and other aggregated sites profiting off of this series is right on the money. People are getting paid off of their hard work and they aren't, it's plain and simple. @Anonymous

    oh! I didn't think about it.. you're right. So maybe if it wasn't updated here but on a site where there are no ads it would have been alright! Or maybe not ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

    shemi May 16, 2017 1:54 pm
    oh! I didn't think about it.. you're right. So maybe if it wasn't updated here but on a site where there are no ads it would have been alright! Or maybe not ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭ lemon

    Also, my friend is Russian, and she said that there are chapters of fools translated to Russian, which are actually locked. So maybe the author was referencing Russians. Just wild speculation.
    But all in all, I think that even if mangago benefits from ad revenue and stuff, it was a mutual benefit for the author too.

    ;_; May 16, 2017 3:11 pm
    Also, my friend is Russian, and she said that there are chapters of fools translated to Russian, which are actually locked. So maybe the author was referencing Russians. Just wild speculation.But all in all, I ... shemi

    yeh, theres no reason for the author to be so upset when its mutual benefit, its not like they would lose viewers on the official website, since its free koreans would still read on the official since they dont have a reason to have to go on here, same with indonesians

    Anonymous May 17, 2017 3:29 am
    Also, my friend is Russian, and she said that there are chapters of fools translated to Russian, which are actually locked. So maybe the author was referencing Russians. Just wild speculation.But all in all, I ... shemi

    Doesn't benefit you if you're getting not getting your cut. They already have chapters up for free as a way to promote it. There is no agreement between these sites and Comica. Regardless of it being the Russian or English, they're still being screwed over.

    Izzy May 17, 2017 3:12 pm
    But all the chapters are free..You just need to wait for it to unlock by itself.So of course the author didn't want people to do the translations and post it somewhere else. @Anonymous

    But even if it is free I don't know what they're saying. They're shooting themselves in the foot by coming down on scanlators that are translating a FREE comic for NO money whatsoever. Their anger is so misplaced honestly.

    yaoi1791 May 18, 2017 6:59 am

    You should still view the raws!!! the adds pay the artist when ever someone views the website
    Here is someone translating for now
    https://snow669.tumblr.com/