I feel like people’s reading comprehension and critical thinking have been lost while reading this cause they’re too fueled by their own emotions and favorite. Those biases are clouding their judgement from seeing that Anna was also not free from blame.
I would say obviously the true villain is rose. With her manipulation.
I also think people are dumb asf for hating on lily just cause she didn’t choose their fave. It’s so clear that lily isn’t really stable mentally. She seems very dependent on others and seeks to feel love and validation. - And to the big part: Anna. Of course because Anna is a servant, she has no power and no choice but to obey. It makes sense why she rejected lily. HOWEVER what doesn’t make sense is her changing her mind last second. Lily was literally asking her about her feelings and wanting to be together, even just wanting to KNOW in secret, how she feels. Yet Anna didn’t give her that. Anna had the choice to at least reassure her that she does love her back. Anna also got mad when they had an argument and so she ignored lily, when lily was clearly being pushed on by rose. These additions just made lily more uneasy, so it makes sense why she wouldn’t believe in Anna. Also the fact that Anna only chose to make a move LAST MINUTE because she felt like lily wouldn’t go with her. If Anna was gonna do it anyway, why even bother rejecting her in the first place.
I’m not saying Anna was totally at fault or the big villain, I’m saying Anna is not fully free of blame for the way things turned out. Lily chose the one who gave her validation, reassurance, over Anna who likely would have never touched her if she hadn’t been desperate to get her to come with her. Anna couldn’t fully give lily what she wanted. Both rose and Anna aren’t a good fit for lily. Rose lacks the true affection and love but give her everything else she wants, and Anna has the love but lacks everything else to give it to her.
I feel like people’s reading comprehension and critical thinking have been lost while reading this cause they’re too fueled by their own emotions and favorite. Those biases are clouding their judgement from seeing that Anna was also not free from blame.
I would say obviously the true villain is rose. With her manipulation.
I also think people are dumb asf for hating on lily just cause she didn’t choose their fave. It’s so clear that lily isn’t really stable mentally. She seems very dependent on others and seeks to feel love and validation.
-
And to the big part: Anna. Of course because Anna is a servant, she has no power and no choice but to obey. It makes sense why she rejected lily. HOWEVER what doesn’t make sense is her changing her mind last second. Lily was literally asking her about her feelings and wanting to be together, even just wanting to KNOW in secret, how she feels. Yet Anna didn’t give her that. Anna had the choice to at least reassure her that she does love her back. Anna also got mad when they had an argument and so she ignored lily, when lily was clearly being pushed on by rose. These additions just made lily more uneasy, so it makes sense why she wouldn’t believe in Anna. Also the fact that Anna only chose to make a move LAST MINUTE because she felt like lily wouldn’t go with her. If Anna was gonna do it anyway, why even bother rejecting her in the first place.
I’m not saying Anna was totally at fault or the big villain, I’m saying Anna is not fully free of blame for the way things turned out. Lily chose the one who gave her validation, reassurance, over Anna who likely would have never touched her if she hadn’t been desperate to get her to come with her. Anna couldn’t fully give lily what she wanted. Both rose and Anna aren’t a good fit for lily. Rose lacks the true affection and love but give her everything else she wants, and Anna has the love but lacks everything else to give it to her.