
He wanted to stake his claim but also blackmail the old guy with the fact that his latest work is plagiarised. Basically his thought process was “I’m mad. He used me for his lover. I want him. I’m going to make him mine and blackmail the other guy so he can’t complain or try to take him back.” It’s pretty fucking toxic actually but honestly this whole book is pretty toxic. I was actually happy about the good BDSM practices but it’s still a toxic book.

That's for explaining I'm still kinda confused tbh. I get he wants to blackmail him by why try to use a sex video as blackmail and not the proof he plagiarised? The thought process he used led the person he wants for himself to be played with by someone else cause I didn't think the old guy was actually his lover and just used the video he'd been sent to blackmail the uke into doing play. So his blackmail actually just got the guy assaulted???? I'm sorry I feel so dumb for not understanding

So his intention was to dissuade the old man from doing anything with the bottom. It failed. That’s why it doesn’t make sense. He assumed the old man was his lover so seeing him “cheating” would have been a dealbreaker but they weren’t dating so it wasn’t. Bottom wasn’t assaulted. Bottom willingly went along with it because he isn’t aware of his own feelings towards the top.

Thanks I understand now although I can't say I agree with it being consensual. After rereading it seems he's only going along with it because he doesn't want anything to happen to the college guy since he's says not that anything but that and then gives his tongue for the cigarette. And the fact he's shown that video of him and then agrees saying sorry sorry for plagiarism again makes it seem he doesn't want this but feels he needs to and to me it seems the old guy is very aware of that and taking advantage of it which is nasty af of him

The old guy says in his own words that the s in sm stands for service since the sadist actually isn’t allowed to do whatever they please. They always have to adhere to the masochist’s preferences. This is what the old guy is going. Even when he had him tied up, he said “even this?” to show the bottom “see? When you say no, you’ll prove my point” but the bottom is an absolute FREAK lol so he stuck his tongue out. He wanted to screw the dude who wrote his favourite erotic novel in hope the guy can make him feel how the book made him feel. He got an opportunity and took it. The old guy was sat next to him the whole time he was in the bathtub, got a towel for him and checked up on his physical and mental wellbeing at the time. Even if he’s only going with it for the ML, he still is consenting since the old guy has given him multiple outs up until now. It’s dubcon at worst and regular old consent at best.

Ah I see what you mean and get where your coming from I would agree dubcon. I guess it's just a case of interpretation to me it feels like old dude is taking advantage along with the warning that's placed in the chapter it made me feel icky however that doesn't mean I'm 200% correct and completely respect others may interpret this differently. It's pretty cool to see how differently 2 people can interpret the same scenes though

If you feel it’s dubcon then it’s probably dubcon (in your eyes). I won’t say it’s noncon though since from how many outs the old guy gave, it isn’t coerced or forced. He is voluntarily doing this but whether or not he’s an active participant or a passive one will determine how dubious his consent was. Everyone will have a different threshold of what dubious counts as. I do agree that I feel icky reading that though. It was written well in that it was uncomfortable and not sexy at all. Especially whatever tf happened in the bathtub. That was weird af and not a BDSM play I’ve ever seen. I think we are both valid and just have different thresholds
wtf is going on