
many reasons. claude isn't well-written, the only reason he is so loved is because he is hot and Athy was actually a grown adult who acted exactly the way he would have wanted her to. too much plot armour for MC. the plot point about the curse is stupid and not convincing enough. immortal person x young human (disgusting, even if she isn't actually a child, he didn't know that early on, when he started liking her). unnecessary plot point of og ML falling for Athy for no apparent reason, with both og leads leading somewhat unhappy lives. too many things I hated here.

Well yeah now that I've kinda grown up this all makes sense but I started reading this from the beginning, and I was immature back then so maybe that's why but idk I love this sm. My roman empire. Idc about plot holes or character arc(like u said, this story lacked in many ways like wdym this all happened coz Lucas gave that "curse" daddy issues)but this is just a diff emotion for me and other ppl.. it doesn't even have to make sense lmao
can't let the gang know how much I hate this fuckass story