Read some comments saying the dad is the male lead… omg I’m sick to my stomach every m...

Omg I just read spoilers and I really wish the white hair guy was the male lead, this story is so shit and I was so invested

I'd like to disagree. I hope it's Raphael

What...? R u fr..?

Yes

They say the ml (father) and fl were og just age-capped couples but fl died and ml turned back time to save so many times but failed them all and adapting the fl and having kids with another woman was the only way to save her...

Nooooo what kind of fvcked up plot is that?. Authornim tryna be quirky but got way too excited and went into dark incestuous route

I understand the intention behind the storyline, but the way the relationships are framed feels too close for comfort, making it hard to enjoy the story. Even with the time travel and saving the FL. Like why adopt someone to save them? then to get in a relationship with them?? Was there no other way?? Why couldn’t he have just find her and marry her?? It still gives off a weird vibe for me. The plot would’ve been fine if she had no relationship with her family. She could have stumbled upon the dad (ML) had a brief conversation, and then sought him out for help because her husband was the abusive one. Or from what I said from above. The story could still work this way without the need for her to be part of that family in the first place.

As for your questions, it seems like the dad (ml) tried to save her without adopting her so many times in so many ways but couldn't. Adoption was the last thing that came to his mind to save her. But now he's too tired and on the edge of breaking to the point he thinks is she even worth it.

(I didn't read the novel myself, it's just what I understood from someone else's spoiler comment)

bc the antagonist from the temple wanted to use her for their evil purposes and to prevent that she needed to be under the protection of a family equally as powerful as the temple. in another timeline, she was actually adopted by sylvian's family and became his sister but that didn't work out. (my theory is that bc alternative brother sylvian doted on her and her life was generally peaceful she didn't develop the necessary strong will and skillset to survive. as opposed to the current timeline in which the abuse forged her to persevere. also alex was obsessed with saving her bc he loved her but that doesn't necessarily apply to sylvian's father.) and alex didn't want to adopt her, and he didn't want to be together with her even when she grew up and she came to love him bc he knew it was fucked up. he just wanted to save her and then retire to the countryside to rest but it was kanna who went to look for him and chased after him. my gripe? considering that rafael sacrificed just as much as alex, it doesn't make sense why she fell for alex, whom she knows is her future father instead of him.

tag it as spoiler please

From what I understood it was actually a reverse harem ending where they "all share her body" and need snusnu from them to stay alive

yeah it is, but she only loves alex while the other mls she likes to some degree

Doesn't matter still a shitshow

SAME

well thats dumb as shit

Having kids(plural?!?? (╯°Д °)╯╧╧) with another woman??!??? Bruuuh naaah ...

Thank you next~ ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~

not disagreeing, the quality really does down hill in the latter half and pacing gets messy, but the plot is interstng and the mls' regret is genuinely cathartic, cuz fmc holds a petty grudge and doesnt forgive them, and this alone makes it more enjoyable than other stories. if it wasnt for the incest, the story would surely be well-recieved as a dark drama OI.

This, if only it wasn’t incest idc how hard people defend this

Ik I read the first half before she saw her mother's painting in the secret room but when I knew from spoilers that "dad" was ML I was even more disappointed cuz tf is this daddy issue filled novel that I feel I wasted my time and energy into???? Even if she is not blood related to him or he was not blood related to the brothers it doesn't matter, incest isn't about just blood she knew him all her life as her neglectful father and practically had no presence in her life or the first half of the novel to end up with him is basically a message the author of turn ur daddy issue into invest if ur dad is Immortal and hot is disgusting

From spoilers I understand that he is not the duke but someone taking his place so she is not related to any of them nor the brothers related to mhim. Which is kinda worse