can someone who's read the novel pls help clarify to me the different timelines she's live...

To me it feels like 2 time lines but I do would like to know how much timelines fr

She’s been through two timelines. The first where she was the belle of high society and married the prince. The empress made her life hell along with the prince. Ines contracted STDs from him to the point she could not bear children. She killed herself with Cárcel’s grandfathers gun in this timeline.

The second, she was 16 when she decided she was going to run away with Emiliano, the painter, to avoid marrying the prince. They lived in poverty and had a child together. Her brother killed Emiliano. I can’t quite remember what happened to the baby or Ines. I think the baby was killed, and I’m pretty sure she killed herself that timeline as well afterwards. But I’m not 100% on that, so don’t take it as canon. I’ll have to go back and reread.

This life, at 6, she chose Cárcel to be betrothed to, in order to avoid the prince again and spare Emiliano. And here we are.

It hasn’t been revealed who Rogelo is yet, I’m pretty sure. I don’t recall him.

She could have lived more lives tho, I haven’t read the novel.

i think its like this
1. ines and carcel
2. ines and cp
3. ines and emiliano
4. ines and carcel
If i remember right from reading spoilers, ines doesnt remember the first timeline, only oscar does
so for her the second timeline is her first
if someone read the novel correct me if i m wrong

There are 4 timelines. Including the one we are reading and following at the moment. Any more than that would be spoiler

This is the 3th one foe ines , the first timeline for her is when she married the crown prince and the second when she run away with that man (forgot his name ) marry and had a child with him but then him and his child got killed by her brother, but ines forgot something spoiler...















That this timeline is actually the 4th one cus actually her first timeline was her and Carcel being inlove so yea that was her first love and she was his first love

Spoiler











Ines married Carcel in the 1st life, Oscar in the 2nd, Emiliano in the 3rd, and Carcel again in 4th. We're on the 4th life.

Haven't read the novel but from how I understood there were 3 timelines;

During the first one she married Oscar and treated Carcel like a nobody while Carcel had a one-sided crush on Ines. In this timeline Ines and her brother were super close to each other. Ines and Carcel were also childhood friends in this timeline but for whatever reason Ines eventually started treating Carcel like he was nothing more than a random stranger (it's currently unclear if Ines was already ignoring Carcel before she got married or if she just went no contact with him as she married Oscar)

During the 2nd timeline she eloped with Emiliano. Carcel helped Emiliano and Ines escape, after which Ines and Emiliano lived happily in a small village that's somewhere near the city where the navy & Carcel were. After Ines' family found them, her brother murdered Emiliano and arranged a new marriage for Ines.

The 3rd timeline is the current timeline where Ines grew sick and tired of everything and chose to marry & then divorce Carcel thinking he was just some harmless pretty boy who was kinda just there. Ines kept some distance from her brother bc she didn't forgive him for killing Emiliano and it's also hinted that Emiliano remembers the timeline where he and Ines were married. Carcel also recently regained his memories from the 1st timeline.

wait?? she married to carcel first?

Spoiler







Yes. She got really sick because Alicia switched her fertility meds and doesn’t remember her 1st marriage yet. I think Oscar is the only one that remembers her first life at this point.

SPOILER??

Alot of ppl are saying twice, 1st with Oscar and 2nd with the painter. But actually she had a very first life with Carcel. It was a tragic end, but they loved each other so much so that Carcel wished to be with Ines in their next life but Ines wished for Carcel’s happiness (which is Ines so…) they keep getting a chance because these wishes have not been fulfilled.

Can you tell me what was the tragic end btw Carcel and Ines ?

Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer / Spoiler Answer


They both died at the same moment at age 28. Ines died from terminal sickness in her bedroom in Calztela and Carcel died on the battlefield fighting a war that the crown prince inadvertently started by accidentally killing a prince of another country. Ironically, when both were dying, Rogelio/Anastasio was with them even though they were in separate places. In about a chapter or so, Ines will be given the memory of her past self dying while Alondra and Anastasio are both by her bedside.

I thought emiliano was within Oscar one (●'◡'●)ﾉ good to know it's 2 different ones. I get confused with time jumping.

Oscar and Alicia are in all of them and are the cause of every tragedy. Alicia’s jealousy in the 1st life, and Oscar’s jealously in life 2 and 3 are why Ines ended up dying.

SPOILER






To the best of my memory, Carcel and Ines spent their last days together because Ines miscarried and she felt she was not being the best wife to Carcel. Carcel did not care, he loved Ines regardless but Carcel was sent on a mission and Ines was still deeply depressed (this is the scene where Ines and carcel are on a field in the first chapter i think) mourning their child. They die at the same time. Carcel on the battlefield and Ines in a field both at the age of 28. At the moment of their death they made a wish. Until they get that wish they both reincarnate and remember their past.

You could be right? But I think in the 3rd one with Emiliano, she remembers her life with Oscar and tries to stop it by running away with Emiliano.