it's a translation error it was Karlyle who was knotting not Ash. So it was Ash's first time.
No no Ash knotted Karlyle when we first saw Karlyle having his rut. (When they had an argument and almost ended their contract). Maybe it was Karlyle's first time but def not Ash's.
Yep author def forgot about chapter 27, Ash knotted Karlyle here
Nope that’s a translation error, they already fixed it on the official site but the uploader here didn’t
I've reread it and noticed a flaw, Ash says it's his first time knotting someone on ch 98 but he definitely knotted Lyle way back ch 36ish when Lyle was on his rut, author prolly forgot lolol