Responses
He didn’t break up first, he broke up two hours prior of the telling of the story. He is just reciting the week(s) before him and what happened. They were always in love/flirting and after the trial they got into a more official relationship since they had already claimed to be fiancé(e)s it wasn't really a change. I do think his tale is also a lie and that he planned for this and made an elaborate story but its not like his story isn’t believable. I just think the way the story is told makes it seem like he has something up his sleeve.
I’m so confused why did the relationship dynamic change so suddenly? Why is he acting in love all of a sudden? Is this just how he plays the story out to barbatos? They broke up and the next chapter was them sleeping together? There was no arrangement to meet barbatos either? It came out of nowhere and now the story is very confusing like the plot changed randomly or something…?