the toxic guy doesn’t have much personality either tho aside from being toxic, no?
literally all we really know is black hair dude is an older brother, liked by MC when they were young, reacted negatively or at least the reaction was perceived negatively by MC, played along with MC when drunk (basically non-consensual shit), same when he was sober but he somewhat manipulated the MC into accepting, and he is annoying/toxic in the present- maybe manipulative too? tho brown hair guy seems to be a bit manipulative too
the brown hair dude has always been nice to MC, minus points was giving MC a non-consensual hickey, kiss, and head, and he communicates his feelings clearly to the point MC is self aware he’s the better option
both need time to build up more but from the get-go, brown hair guy all the way
ISN’T THAT A KID? HELLO?
Please just end up with the brown hair guy- ik poly would be cool to get more rep of but not when one is a confusing piece of shit and the other is a minor… best option and even mc thought so himself, is the brown-haired guy. I hope he’s end game