Novel VS Manhwa

SJ02 October 23, 2024 2:58 pm

Novel has a lot of better shown aspects, etc. However, I wasn’t a big fan of Edith in the novel, so if they stop making her a self-righteous saint in the manhwa (and give Cliff what he deserves) then I’m all for it. I will like this version better. Novel was too forgiving and Edith was “kind” to the point of becoming an enabler. She wasn’t their only victim, she had no right to rid them of consequences they should’ve paid for their crimes. And Cliff is in no way qualified to lead people. Sorry not sorry, unpopular opinion, but Edith in the novel was just not great.

Responses
    Amies October 23, 2024 4:16 pm

    Correct me if I'm not wrong, the novel said that everyone around the 'author' are brainwashed by her specially Cliff since he was the closest to the 'author'. But yeah, I can say that she's really forgiving to the 'author' who did all those shts.

    Yulieee October 23, 2024 5:29 pm

    For real, this is the only thing that I hate abt her character, it's her being too self-righteous that it's actually so draining to read

    SJ02 October 23, 2024 5:34 pm
    Correct me if I'm not wrong, the novel said that everyone around the 'author' are brainwashed by her specially Cliff since he was the closest to the 'author'. But yeah, I can say that she's really forgiving to ... Amies

    But Cliff didn’t change even after brainwashing was broken, so…

    SJ02 October 23, 2024 5:38 pm
    For real, this is the only thing that I hate abt her character, it's her being too self-righteous that it's actually so draining to read Yulieee

    Thank u! Honestly, no one ever mentioned that so I thought I was the only one. Her “kindness” is to the point of rather than her being a victim, her helping the perpetrators. It’s absurd. It seems like author tried to portray her as some kind of saint, but she’s just unbearable in my opinion. Also, I don’t get why her forgiving those parents must also mean ML forgiving their neglect. Yeah, I just don’t like how the story ended. Edith is not as good of a person as author tries to potray her to be. So I really hope it changes in the manhwa

    Yulieee October 23, 2024 5:44 pm
    Thank u! Honestly, no one ever mentioned that so I thought I was the only one. Her “kindness” is to the point of rather than her being a victim, her helping the perpetrators. It’s absurd. It seems like au... SJ02

    Yesss the ending in the novel is just not it for me. I really hoped that those who caused her pain would face much harsher consequences. Instead, they seemed to get off too easily and were forgiven without much struggle. Take Cliff and the duke, for example, and even Lize, like wtffff

    SJ02 October 23, 2024 5:53 pm
    Yesss the ending in the novel is just not it for me. I really hoped that those who caused her pain would face much harsher consequences. Instead, they seemed to get off too easily and were forgiven without much... Yulieee

    100% agreed. It’s not for me at all either. She tried to save her any chance she got, Lize would go unpunished if she could’ve helped it. I don’t understand why ML had to forgive his family just like that either, them playing the role of good grandparents was very ironic and bitter to me. I didn’t like the ending at all. Edith was just not it. I really hope manhwa changes that