FINALLY

Yuki no Sora(⌐■-■) August 23, 2024 7:23 pm

I kept fucking saying it but Fl had options she is literally in the most opportune place to gain info through gossip and the like her father inst so powerful that he could restrict so much info from her. And as the only daughter she should be more aware of what the house is going to look like since she would be the caretaker even when married. SHE HAD THE CHOICE TO LOOK THINGS UP AND FIND THINGS OUT she just didn't choose those options. She choose to be ignorant not because of only her family but simply because she had no interest in the outside world. She doesn't even know how to take care of her self and u can't say because she's royalty, even an interest in making yourself a midnight snack or making something u tasted before should have ignored her curiosity but FL has no curiosity. She's like a doll with no thought, the ballerina on the musical box she will keep dancing to the same toon until it's broken and she has to crawl her way through janky notes.

Responses
    SoulfulYURI August 23, 2024 11:17 pm

    She didn't need to though, she just wasnt/isn't that type of person. She could have but for what purpose? It would have served her nothing, it doesn't make sense to have those expectations on her. You would be hard pressed to find actual high ranking nobles making themselves midnight snacks or thinking "wow, I enjoyed that I should make it" You are thinking from a modern perspective but that just simply wasn't the reality back then.
    The OI you read, those are modern women sent into medieval times and so they have those hobbies. This is an actual noblewoman doing what they really would have done.
    The reality is she and everyone in her immediate vicinity did not have to take care of themselves the way you or I do and so her perspective from then is very different. What I appreciate about her is that when she needed to change, she could. She pushed aside everything she knew from when she was born to learn and do better.

    Tl;dr: putting your modern expectations on her is crazy

    Nemesis August 23, 2024 11:40 pm

    girl you're looking into this in a prospective as a reader who have read the entire context of this story. Just look at Marie Antoinette. She tried to help the peasants but it was tone deaf. Literally gave them mini houses to live in but to nobility it looked like a fucking freakshow. You are speaking in a place where it's something you would. You're just like her ex husband lmao

    Yuki no Sora(⌐■-■) August 23, 2024 11:41 pm
    She didn't need to though, she just wasnt/isn't that type of person. She could have but for what purpose? It would have served her nothing, it doesn't make sense to have those expectations on her. You would be ... SoulfulYURI

    I'm talking about a perspective of when she could have been a child and want to be interested in different things and did I say anything about modern,no. But it's just a basic example of what she could have had curiosity about and I have expectations of no one because that's the worse thing you can do to a person or character. But even as a nobel lady no matter how "isolated" they were they would still have social circles, the rumors of war still would have been circulating or would begin to circulate. And if so it would be something having to do with her father who was a minister of defense or war, and she's a daddies girls so you would have thought that at one point she would be concerned about her father atleast. But even when her father died she didn't try to learn anything although she was in a miserable situation but she didn't even try to figure out what lead to it she just heard gossip from the servants etc

    Yuki no Sora(⌐■-■) August 23, 2024 11:44 pm
    girl you're looking into this in a prospective as a reader who have read the entire context of this story. Just look at Marie Antoinette. She tried to help the peasants but it was tone deaf. Literally gave them... Nemesis

    I don't know who that is but it's still just a perspective based on accessibility even at the end she said she had choices, she just chose not to choose them. And hey if that's what you want to see it as go ahead

    SoulfulYURI August 24, 2024 2:18 am
    I'm talking about a perspective of when she could have been a child and want to be interested in different things and did I say anything about modern,no. But it's just a basic example of what she could have had... Yuki no Sora(⌐■-■)

    But your perspective is one of a modern person, not what is actually going on. You didn't have to say anything, you are the one expecting her to be this whole different person from what her reality would dictate because you believe she should just do these things that literally no person anywhere near her was doing lol

    They were purposely keeping that stuff away from her though? Her father was extremely high ranking and influential, it would have been easy to keep her in the dark.

    We'll have to agree to disagree because you aren't getting it, that's okay.

    Yuki no Sora(⌐■-■) August 24, 2024 2:55 am
    But your perspective is one of a modern person, not what is actually going on. You didn't have to say anything, you are the one expecting her to be this whole different person from what her reality would dictat... SoulfulYURI

    Maybe I'm just saying it this way because I'm a theater kid and had to do a lot of reading on stuff but she is a musician which means she could have watched plays in which she was interested in scores. And seeking information isn't acting like a normal person it what a person need to have a better understanding of their world, that's why common sense isn't common until it taught. But anyways back to the plays they could depict current event going on around her, even from her father's time etc. I don't really care much about her as a character but from a performing arts perspective it's the fact that she never tried to seek different perspectives from performing arts or irl situations I guess. It's hard to explain this and I would think at this point I already showed I don't care much about her as a character but more about the social circles and information she had access too. Which couldn't be completely blocked from her because she is in the music circle although catered to nobility, but I'm pretty sure she would have been interested in where the artist inspo for their pieces came from because her house is also surrounded in art and she frequently meets with other artists to. I just don't understand how she would be completely unaware because her father can't control everything and everyone especially if they are foreign performers or even the stage hands in the back that prep things.

    As I said I don't know how to explain this clearly but maybe I'm just overestimating the world building