I might be wrong but this is what I remembered from past spoilers....

TheGirl August 3, 2024 6:53 am

So yes in her first life she died of old aged.

Second life she was reborn and while she did take her anger out on Luca he honestly didn't hate him deep down. After she found out someone wanted to kill him she went undercover and pretended to be on the evil guy side in hopes of protecting Luca. But she was found out and killed. Luca later learns this and in his mind she was the only one who loved him even though she didn't know it. This is why he is so protective of her.

Third life at this point in time she is remembering everything and as we know trying to fix past mistakes

Responses
    Oikawa plush August 3, 2024 6:31 pm

    Where was the last part of the 2nd life like the one where she tries to save him

    TheGirl August 3, 2024 7:00 pm
    Where was the last part of the 2nd life like the one where she tries to save him Oikawa plush

    Honestly I don't remember, the spoiler was so long ago i don't know in what tab it was in.

    Raradesh August 8, 2024 2:48 am

    Wait did i miss remembered, at earliest chapter said she got killed by luca for revenge not taking care of him? That wasn't true/happened at all?

    shuntarou21 August 8, 2024 4:55 am
    Wait did i miss remembered, at earliest chapter said she got killed by luca for revenge not taking care of him? That wasn't true/happened at all? Raradesh

    Nope she was killed by Franz guy I think? Iirc there was a short moment in the webtoon chap 34 where Judith being tied up and was in front of Franz who was disappointed at her for not being cooperative and messed up his plans instead.. I think Franz reached out to Judith in first life in attempt to use her against Luca, and Judith probably tried to play along for a bit, but actually messed up his plan instead and was killed after by him