I don't understand why it's ONLY this bl getting criticized when there are hundreds if not...

Hina-$VL August 1, 2024 7:16 am

I don't understand why it's ONLY this bl getting criticized when there are hundreds if not thousands of other bl's with similar messed up themes. I don't see roses and champagne, codename Anastasia, low tide in twilight, lost in cloud, painter of the night/ other popular bls getting criticized for having sa/rape in their stories...

Responses
    Chiaki August 1, 2024 9:27 am

    I see other works get criticized all the time but I think the main factor as to why Jinx pops up the most is because of the popularity of Mingwa and her widely known Manhwa themselves.
    You can't be into BL Manhwa without having to come across Jinx at least once in your life whether you want to or not.
    From what I've seen, more than half of BL readers name BJ Alex as their first Manhwa for the genre and regard it as a classic and favorite to this day.

    Mayo August 1, 2024 7:52 pm
    Bruh then u have not been online cause everytime I hear about any of those it's about how brutally SA the characters were, it's not only this story...the authtor is also a major part of it cause she states stuf... romeo

    nah man, this is weird didn't jaekyung and dan come to an agreement of havin sex and jaekyung paying him 4 it, then ion see why you niggas consider it as SA bro, DAN is literally gettin fucking said bro, jaekyung didn't do anything without DAN consent brah he agreed at the v beginnin as far as I remember

    Hina-$VL August 1, 2024 8:03 pm
    nah man, this is weird didn't jaekyung and dan come to an agreement of havin sex and jaekyung paying him 4 it, then ion see why you niggas consider it as SA bro, DAN is literally gettin fucking said bro, jaekyu... Mayo

    Even if he agreed in the beginning- it's clear Dan didn't want to do it in many of the Jinx chapters. Dan even tells jaekyung to use condoms in one of the chaps, which jaekyung chooses to ignore (that is also considered another form of rape). Dan also clearly said no to doing it in the public showers in the earlier chaps- which is another example of rape. Even if Dan agreed to the contract- it doesn't excuse the fact that Jaekyung ignored Dan's consent and comfort. Just bc he agreed in the beginning doesn't mean Jaekyung has the right to force him to uncomfortable situations and intercourse.

    Hina-$VL August 1, 2024 8:05 pm
    I see other works get criticized all the time but I think the main factor as to why Jinx pops up the most is because of the popularity of Mingwa and her widely known Manhwa themselves. You can't be into BL Manh... Chiaki

    Yeah I agree I think it's a mixture of both popularity and bl becoming more mainstream in general on tiktok from what I've seen.

    Chiaki August 1, 2024 8:18 pm
    Yeah I agree I think it's a mixture of both popularity and bl becoming more mainstream in general on tiktok from what I've seen. Hina-$VL

    Yes especially on TikTok, when a new chapter was released at least half of my feed was Jinx lol

    sam August 2, 2024 5:57 am

    putting lost in the cloud in the same spectrum as jinx is absolutely insane.

    Hina-$VL August 2, 2024 3:21 pm
    putting lost in the cloud in the same spectrum as jinx is absolutely insane. sam

    SA is SA no matter the spectrum. Cirrus kissed Skylar without his consent.

    jojo August 2, 2024 3:45 pm

    THIS., i am telling the same thing every time this literally has the most generic plot rich guy/ poor guy relationship etc i guess this gets more fame cause the art is good ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

    BaileyBot August 2, 2024 7:33 pm

    All of those are shit on a lot. The fans in the Jinx comments are more delulu though. In those other manhwa, you might find 1 in a 30 comments defending the ml, but here it's like 1 in 10 comments.