Did I miss something?

LessThanThree March 5, 2017 3:54 am

Even after finishing it I'm confused. Niko was able to kill that girl whose name I can never remember because he used her BDD against her, but how did he know she was trans in the first place? She only revealed it to the MC and his girlfriend (seriously, I can remember the names of virtually no one in this series). Did he overhear them or something? She passes, so he shouldn't have been able to tell. That's a pretty big detail they skipped over. Did I miss something here, or is that just a gaping plot hole the mangaka left open?

Responses
    Anon ✨ March 5, 2017 4:00 am

    I'm pretty sure it's just a gaping plot hole :')

    ChibiMichie April 18, 2017 10:10 pm

    i dont think he told anyone about his crossdressing. he just got found out when his dress got ripped with knife. it's pretty easy from then on to know that the person who is supposedly a girl is actually a guy. threatening to cut his hair confirmed it

    ChibiMichie April 18, 2017 10:12 pm

    nonetheless i am glad it was a happy ending and not a plot twist where supposedly the psychiatrist wasn't the villian and then the mc dies out of the game by the hands of his "supposedly" lover :)

    LessThanThree April 18, 2017 10:25 pm
    i dont think he told anyone about his crossdressing. he just got found out when his dress got ripped with knife. it's pretty easy from then on to know that the person who is supposedly a girl is actually a guy.... ChibiMichie

    When did HER dress get ripped again? I don't recall that. And HER having short hair wouldn't give any confirmation that SHE was born in the wrong body.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 1:00 am
    When did HER dress get ripped again? I don't recall that. And HER having short hair wouldn't give any confirmation that SHE was born in the wrong body. LessThanThree

    read the part again when the niko dude slipped into the room. he used his knife to cut the dress as "she" was paralized in bed. And you should even read what i said thoroughly and making a whole new thing up. I said niko confirmed it by cutting off "her long hair" after he saw "her chest" after ripping her dress. There was no loop hole. You just didn't watch right. Cutting the hair was a torture to "her" and by her strong reaction of denying "her identity being taken away",she eventually bit her tongue and died. :) how about read the part again till niko's confession and come back to claim you are right.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 1:02 am
    When did HER dress get ripped again? I don't recall that. And HER having short hair wouldn't give any confirmation that SHE was born in the wrong body. LessThanThree

    oh and don't forget the room is soundproof :) have fun searching for the faults in what i just said. game on(๑•ㅂ•)و✧

    LessThanThree April 19, 2017 3:04 am
    oh and don't forget the room is soundproof :) have fun searching for the faults in what i just said. game on(๑•ㅂ•)و✧ ChibiMichie

    You sound very touchy, lol. It was a genuine question. Not an accusation that you were wrong. I just don't see how she (not "she") was figured out. From ripping the dress? What did that reveal? You'll have to give me the chapter number so I can go back and check. Either way, why would he have the inclination that she's trans. She clearly passes. He just randomly knew she was trans. It seems like a gaping plothole.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 3:31 pm

    since you don't wanna search it up yourself,sure. I'll gladly give you the chapter :) also words don't always give away what a person hides but the eyes can

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 3:34 pm

    actually there wasnt no speech as he was gagged :D if you cant slip into the character and think of "oh he got killed" why not think this way "she has the chest of a man",how about lets threaten her..."hmm look at him squeeling when i grab his hair and cut it off mercilessly-he definitely thinks he's a girl" and btw its not being trans,more a trap wanting to be female. trans is something different.

    LessThanThree April 19, 2017 3:35 pm
    since you don't wanna search it up yourself,sure. I'll gladly give you the chapter :) also words don't always give away what a person hides but the eyes can ChibiMichie

    Not sure what that last sentence meant. And I thought you had the chapter on hand, which is why I asked. If not, I'll look it up myself. You sound extremely passive aggressive.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 3:39 pm

    read ch. 09 page 36 onwards to confirm "her clothes being cut where "her breast turns out to be a male chest" and analyse" her attitude when the scissors came close to the hair till it was cut".

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 3:41 pm

    thats the only way the murderer could had guess the supposedly female was actually a male.

    LessThanThree April 19, 2017 3:48 pm
    thats the only way the murderer could had guess the supposedly female was actually a male. ChibiMichie

    You entirely missed the original point. The murderer did that because he knew she was trans. My question is how did he know that in the first place. He didn't just cut her shirt open and then say, "Oh, wow, she's trans?" He knew that in advance. THAT is the gaping plot hole.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 3:54 pm
    Not sure what that last sentence meant. And I thought you had the chapter on hand, which is why I asked. If not, I'll look it up myself. You sound extremely passive aggressive. LessThanThree

    the last sentence was incomplete. my bad. what i meant to say is "words don't always give away what a person hides but the eyes can reveal what a person is hiding".
    If you connect it to the murderer,he had a gag so he wouldn't be able to question if "the girl" really is a man as a mean of torment. there is no way he could had heard them as the room is soundproof. all that is left is what? the eye! and you know these words"seeing is believing",right?

    well anyway i may had sound aggressive but just wanted to prove that there was nothing missing-hence "game on". Everything was there. And if you are mistaken,you gotta get into the character whose senses has been taken away and think of how they could react as a victim or a murderer. (▰˘◡˘▰)

    LessThanThree April 19, 2017 3:57 pm

    No, still doesn't make sense, and Anon agrees with me. It's clear she passed, and so there is no explanation as to why Niko knew she was trans.
    Also, she is a she. She's not a "girl" she's a girl. She isn't a crossdressing man. She is a woman who was born in the wrong body.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 3:58 pm

    while reading such mangas,its like playing the role of a detective,guessing who and how they do stuff. You could say i am quite into it like a prosecuter and an attorney protecting their clients in the court ヾ(☆▽☆) i gave evidence and all you need is to give evidence to prove me wrong. Don't sweat over it too much

    LessThanThree April 19, 2017 3:58 pm

    I'm not saying the series wasn't good (though I think Dolls Code was better). I'm just saying that it wasn't all thought through well. It seemed very rushed.

    LessThanThree April 19, 2017 3:59 pm

    But you didn't give any evidence. In fact, I've provided more evidence than you have.

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 4:04 pm
    But you didn't give any evidence. In fact, I've provided more evidence than you have. LessThanThree

    i did give you the chapter that you asked for. I even said "seeing is a proof". Surely niko wouldn't know until he cut the clothes but you're probably thinking "how did he know to cut the clothes". its more like "lets have some fun and cut off her clothes before killing him like how the doll got smashed to push her to the limit before she dies".

    ChibiMichie April 19, 2017 4:08 pm

    also that psychiatrist wouldn't be able to know to tell niko. after all he is part of the game and his life is pretty much being gambled as well. Informations about others are disclosed regardless of him working for the organization. Just gotta connect how niko changed his tactic after seeing "the unusual". He confirms what he saw by cutting her hair which brought her to the absolute limit resulting her to bite off her tongue and die.