So Judith is remembering right now, she didn't just go to the past as she had always been Judith. She lived her life normally and died in Korea, being reborn as Judith. She either had her memories and for the sake of Luca's future happiness from knowing the novel she chose to mistreat him (although I bet it wasn't at bad as we are being led to believe and this theory might hold some weight because we see Judith dream about her capture by Franz in the novel and she seemed like she expected it) OR she didn't have her memories and mistreated Luca and when Luca turned back time with his wish she suddenly remembered her past life, but forgot her life as Judith, believing to have reincarnated after getting hit by a car but it was just a distorted memory. Its a bit confusing, especially to explain in text, but she is the OG Judith in all time lines and she just forgot, possibly due to Luca's wish (which I assume was for happiness and a Judith without her memories as Judith would be nicer to him and thus give him happiness)
ahh .. i kinda get it, i kinda don't. BUT THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE EXPLANATION REGARDLESS
omygosh this is such a good explanation, thank you
I'm confused. Why is everyone saying that Judith was the og aunt who mistreated luca ?? Did she really came in the past ?? I thought it was rebirth after she died in her normal life. Haven't read the novel so idk where this is going but I assumed it was smth like how luca went back in time. Can someone please spoil me ??