Haven't read the novel but she is the OG Judith. Wether she had her memories of her past life when she abused Luca or not is up in the air
It’s just kinda weird to me. Cause like…so you have a completely normal life in the modern world, but when you transmigrate you end up being a pretty crappy person to your nephew? Unless in the first time she didn’t remember the life in the modern world until now? (Idk if I’m making sense)
I have two guesses. Either she didn't remember and it was only once Luca turned back time her memories partially came back while also making her forget she was original Judith (but she still had some memories since we see young Judith flashbacks that she shouldn't know otherwise and its kinda crazy she never questioned them lol). The biggest evidence for this to me is her remembering Judith as a kid saying her sister was prettier and that felt very childish and made it seem like she didn't have her memories.
The other option is that she did remember the first go around and she chose to play her role as a bad aunt because she thought it would bring Luca happiness since she had read the novel and she might not have wanted to re-live life again if she had been content in her first life. This also has some evidence as when Judith dreamed of when Franz killed Judith in one of the early chapters that Judith seemed to know what was going to happen and didn't seem at all worried or particularly evil.
Someone who read the novel come unconfuse me please!
So the OG Judith was a bad parental figure to the ML. But if Judith transmigrated as a baby, wouldn’t that mean SHE was the one that was bad? Or is she just getting memories from OG Judith?