Responses
The thing Carlisle has that Edmund never did was his parents love which is why I consider Edmund to be more tragic and more of a victim is. Carlisle Will always have his mother’s and father’s and grandfather’s love. Edmund doesn’t.
I will concede that he is a victim because he doesn’t deserve to die he’s just a child but I think Edmund still has him beat due to the tragedy of his situation.
Edmund Is the only true victim in this story. Literally nothing goes right for him it is actually a tragedy for him. I would love a side story just about him bc wow he deserves to be happy even for a day