I can forgive Reynold bc he was young and dumb but the duke….. idk I just can’t imagine adopting a child to then neglect them to the point that I don’t notice them getting mistreated and abused in my own home.
what abt the other brother I think his name was Derek or sum cuz I heard he had a yellow circle for forbidden love and I saw coms saying like they can't forgive him cuz he doesn't apologize n that he's unforgivable or sum like that idk
Yes that’s why if Rey truly know the depth of his mistakes (like it’s revealed that she’s being abused by needles or sum) and beg for fogiveness, he’s redeemable
Btw for the 2nd comment
there is this moment in the novel where the duke explains that Penelope has been his daughter since the day he adopt her. And he don’t know how to take care of his sons, let alone take care of a daughter. That’s why he just let her misbehave & give her everything she wants to “compensate”
It doesn’t justify anything but the novel’s writing make the duke confession seems so sincere & he’s been so observant towards her, even Penelope don’t realize that she held her breath whenever she’s super angry but the duke realized although he dont know what to do, so I kinda melt a bit. But it’s also sad scene because Penelope realize the OG Penelope died from her anger towards the family (she held her breath whenever she’s angry)
Derek is iredeemable he can go ahead to fall head first & die
Since the novel is very thorough about describing the events & feelings, I feel like I can forgive the duke & reynald. HOWEVER, i dont know whats different, but the manhwa makes me mad to all member of the duke family unless they beg and BEG for fogiveness