Funny

So far no changes so it's not that invalid. We're alrdy like 1/3 into the story and no changes only cuts to make manhwa readers brainwashed. Guess it worked LOL Ines got Carcel brainwashed before and now even got you readers brainwashed lmaooo

He didn't even fall for her bc he realized Ines is beautiful. Just another Carcel hater showing they can't read. It literally said during the wedding that when someone else said Ines is beautiful and they didn't know, Carcel said she's always the same. He knew. He had always planned to be faithful AFTER marriage. Go read the beginning. He said it in ch2 before he even have the dream.

The funny part if Carcel haters thinking they can read and saying his actions so far were bad bc what? He slept around bc he's free to? Ines practically ignored him for over 10 years and he should've clinged to her? He's bad for letting himself live freely when she doesn't even care about him? If ppl want to use her past as an excuse that's fine, but you should know she was only unstable from 16-20 so what does that say about her whole life before 16? She was fine and ignoring him while also using him. I still suggest you better reread bc I can literally pull out lines to show you can't read.

ch2
If that's the case, I should have as much fun as I can before the wedding. At least then if I have to live out the rest of my life like a monk, I won't have any regrets. My scoundrel-like ways will soon be behind me.

Ch15
Ihar: I can understand why you can't take your eyes off of her.
Carcel: I don't care if anyone understands it or not.
Carcel: Yes, it was obvious that everyone was shcoked. Ines was still receiving a combination of surprised, admiring, and shocked looks from everyone. She smiled kindly at those who gazed in astonishment... while simply ignoring those who annoyed her. She behaved naturally as she had always rules over the other nobles in high society. But Ines is still Ines. All that had changed was her hair and clothes. She may have smiled more which was a rare occurrence but it was just another expression she wore. Even so, the whole world treated her as though everything about her had changed. It was ridiculous.

Looks like Carcel can see she still the same. More like readers are the one who only like her bc she's beauitiful. Carcel actually knows Ines. Can't say the same about readers like you.

You want to know why only novel readers seem to be defending Carcel? It's because manhwa readers let just ch1 of Carcel make them blind to the rest of the story about him. Novel readers know the whole story so we can read less bias than readers who hate him and read the manhwa selectively.

In their defense tho Carcel himself apologizes to Ines after he got "exposed" meaning he himself knows he was doing something he shouldn't have. And he was even baffled that Ines wasn't mad and threatening to break up the engagement, did Ines lead him astray into seeking out other women, yes, but Carcel also let himself fall into temptation which was bad and sleep with various women with the intention of never letting Ines know, also yes.

What matters is that he's faithful NOW because now they're married if he was still trying to lie and flirt with other women then he'd be irredeemable trash but he's not.

ALSO side note if anyone's disgusted with the ML for sleeping around technically the FL already slept with 3 men (although two were in her previous lives) and she's skilled enough for even her husband to think to himself "(oh she's skilled)" so hah

Thank you babes. People be acting like Carcel is a child that cannot think straight. He’s a grown ass man that even acknowledges that he was wrong but them people keep babying him

He's been brainwashed and manipulated since he was 6. Ofc even if he an adult if he's been manipualted since he was 6, he would take a while to get out of the manipulation. You talk like there aren't adults falling for cults or ppl groomed.

Even if he apologized and got expose, didn't you read what OP saying? OP saying he just fell for her because Ines is beautiful. That wasn't Carcel. I'm just saying the funny part is how they hating on Carcel when what they say about Carcel isn't even true and the manhwa shows it so idk wtf they reading. Clearly they can't read.

If they mad about any guy falling for Ines bc she's beautiful, then that's Emiliano but no one saying anything about that. Carcel didn't fall for Ines bc she's beautiful. He had liked her since he was a kid and she led him astray so he chose freedom. Even if he know it wrong Ines led him astray and he was too young to do other choice. When he is already an adult like someone say, he's already been brainwashed to think he hates Ines to not care about her.

This is the man who fell for Ines bc she is beautiful and it's not Carcel.
Ch11:
...You are so beautiful. In fact from the moment I first saw you... I knew that I was helpless to stop myself from falling in love with you.

Looks like it's Emiliano who is more shallow with his love, but Carcel haters can't read and think it's Carcel.

He apologizes bc he is someone with right mindset but why isn't Ines apologizing yet? If you look at the comments, people baby Ines more and she's been a grown adult far longer than Carcel. They excuse her bc of her past but her past shouldn't excuse her for using and manipulating Carcel. If she didn't force him to marry her then he wouldn't even be call a cheater. He nvr married in past life and she thought he was a playboy in the past life but if he was a playboy and not marrying, no one going to hold it against him. He could've been the same in this lifetime but she forced him into an engagement.

If i'm brainwashed because of the manhwa you're brainwashed and blinded by the novel lmaooo. I don't give af about the novel. This isn't a novel, it's a MANHWA, so stick with it for god's sake lmao. I said what i said and my opinion won't change because of a novel reader because for sure your opinion is again invalid. And if you stayed a little bit more open minded you'd see that i also wrote that we should WAIT and SEE LATER again when the story will progress if we want to change our opinion about Carcel (cuz it's possible and it can happen since there's character development) but noooo... the novel readers keep coming for the rescue even when it's not needed lmaoo.

My opinions aren't that invalid when I can see everything in the manhwa is EXACTLY in the novel. I doubt ppl like you can change your feelings about Carcel bc he doesn't get character development. It's Ines in the novel that gets it more but the manhwa just cuts them out so everyone always think she right. Carcel only gets reveal more about his initial, true character that ppl been blind to all this time. They're not character development bc he's always been like that. If ppl hate him, they'll keep hating him bc the manhwa cuts a lot and don't care about showing both their true full characters. If you still can't see that he had always loved Ines and that Ines likes him already then anything after that will just random to you bc Ines will already accept Carcel soon. She can see his love and care and want to accept him, but haters can't see it and still hate him so the story is already moving along and what had these haters been readnig all along then that Ines can see it and they can't?

I also don't trust your reading comprehension even just for the manhwa alone cuz I just post those lines DIRECTLY from the manhwa. You can't even read and understand them and making up things bc of your bias hate.

So I'll just show this again DIRECTLY from the manhwa that you keep bringing up.

ch2
Carcel:If that's the case, I should have as much fun as I can before the wedding. At least then if I have to live out the rest of my life like a monk, I won't have any regrets. My scoundrel-like ways will soon be behind me.

Ch15
Ihar: I can understand why you can't take your eyes off of her.
Carcel: I don't care if anyone understands it or not.
Carcel: Yes, it was obvious that everyone was shcoked. Ines was still receiving a combination of surprised, admiring, and shocked looks from everyone. She smiled kindly at those who gazed in astonishment... while simply ignoring those who annoyed her. She behaved naturally as she had always rules over the other nobles in high society. But Ines is still Ines. All that had changed was her hair and clothes. She may have smiled more which was a rare occurrence but it was just another expression she wore. Even so, the whole world treated her as though everything about her had changed. It was ridiculous.

This is the man who fell for Ines bc she is beautiful and it's not Carcel.
Ch11:
Emiliano:...You are so beautiful. In fact from the moment I first saw you... I knew that I was helpless to stop myself from falling in love with you.




You: And also doesn't change the fact that his actions so far were bad up until the moment when he realised that Ines is beautiful and wanted to stay faithful to her.

Manhwa: Carcel been planning to stay faithful after marriage. Carcel nvr realized that Ines is beautiful out ot nowhere and changed his mind. He thought she was the same as always. Emiliano was the one who fell for her beauty.

Idk why are you still here. Still proving the fact that you're also brainwashed from the novel. At still proved the fact that he was a man with bad actions and reputation before he married Ines, since he also said those words. We don't know how the novel portrayed the characters especially Carcel because that's not the point here, and frankly speaking we don't care about that. The only ones who care are people like you who are pressed and are up in every comment with other made up fake accounts hating other opinions. If you're so stuck on the fact that maaaaaybe maybe Carcel "knew" what Ines's full potential would be it was still buried deep down in him and AGAIN realised it after officially getting married to her and seeing how beautiful she is. I'm not a Carcel hater, I don't hate him. I just don't like him at the moment cuz he shows his hypocritical sides and that's that. But thanks anyway for sharing the direct lines from the manhwa that actually helps my arguments here. Appreciate it really. And about Emiliano was superficial from his side too (and i actually don't like that) but at least he wasn't acting arrogant or had bad reputation behind him.

Like I said, you keep saying he only changed bc he saw how beautiful she is when his words specifically nvr said that. Those are YOUR words not his. Stop making up story in your own head just bc you hate him. Where did my lines prove your argument right? He never said he fell for her bc of her beauty. He said she's always been the same. It's other people who think she just became beautiful. It's people like you who only simp for her bc she's beautiful. He never said he fell for her bc of that. Once again you prove you can't read. He was saying how ridiculous others are for saying she changed just bc she became beautiful when "Ines is still Ines." You rly can't read.

Carcel can see through her beauty that everyone is gawking about, that she's the same. She's still ignoring those who annoy her and still behaving aristocratic as if she's over them. He can see she's still the same. It's others who think she changed just bc she's beautiful. He nvr said she's beautiful now so she's different. He said she's the same and all that change is the appearance that made everyone else think she's different.

You are a Carcel hater bc your hate is making up lines for him to paint him in a bad light.

Read again my reply and think it over because if you don't believe in my reading comprehension i don't believe in yours. Carcel also literally admitted that was bad and did bad things and that someday they'll come back to bit him in the ass. What more do you want? With your other fake account you don't deserve anyone siding with your opinion. Just get outta here and stop giving me notifications. You're literally obsessed. You don't deserve the opportunity to read this manhwa, better stick with your novel only.

Carcel apologizes for things he didn't do too so even if he admit he slept around and felt bad for it, he will apologize for it. He can think it's bad but when you think about Ines' side, was what he did bad? Was Ines hurt? She manipulated him so not like he did it on his own. She know it's not his fault. She even said so ni the manhwa but why no one notice her saying that? Everyone just jumping the gun to criminalize him when he says something negative but can't even read the positive things about him. He can say it's bad but he doesn't know that Ines was behind it all the time. If someone made you do something bad and you don't know someone make you do it or what was even going on, who is more at fault? This isn't a fake account but yeah I made it cause of ppl who can't read like you. It's funny how you think I don't deserve the opportunity to read the manhwa when you don't even understand the manhwa more than me.

And you have shown many times that you can't read bc Carcel still never said he fell in love for Ines bc of her beauty and he never decide to become loyal bc of her beauty. Ch2 he alrdy said sleeping around is only for before marriage. This was before he even rekindle his love for her again. He also never even fell for her beauty when she only became beautiful at the wedding and he didn't fall for her at the wedding. He said she's still the same as always. It was other people who thought she just became beautiful and suddenly like her more but he saw through her true self behind the changed appearance. Carcel always knew her well. When they married, he could see she was being suspicious being nice to the servants, but people like you who can't read don't see that. Carcel also said he had always love her. Guess you also didn't read that. That meant he had liked her even before she became beautiful bc he liked her when they were young and then stopped liking her bc she kept turning him down. If people going to say he's bad for sleeping around bc the girl he liked not even trying to have a relationship, that's fking stupid. You're telling me he's suppose to try to keep sucking up to her from 6-23 even when she kept turning him away? I'm sorry, but him lasting from 6-16 is already a long time of trying to be good to a girl who didn't care about him. He's "bad" according to you bc he decided to live freely when the girl wasn't interested in a relationship. Irl girls wouldn't want a clingy guy to keep trying when they keep rejecting them. I don't see what Carcel did as wrong when he stopped being clingy to the girl who kept turning him down. If you think he could've broke the engagement, then that's also stupid of you when the engagement is bc of Ines using the empress to make sure they'll marry. He was waiting for her to break it and she wouldn't.

Keep yapping about how Carcel is in the right and Ines is in the wrong when she actually didn't do anything. Carcel did all the things on his own, is his own fault. And he admits it. Idk how many times i should tell you, i don't hate the dude the problem i have with him is his hypocrisy. And the problem i have with Ines is because of her coldness. Also you should know that you can't manipulate someone if you don't have contact with that someone. And if you can't understand the problem i have with you, you also prove that you can't read and that your understanding ability is of a 5year old. And you're also continuing to prove your obsessiveness. Like, dude i'm tired, you can't change the facts that were given in the manhwa and that some of the people here legit don't like Carcel. I think your real problem is with the author that made the manhwa since you're unsatisfied, but the fact won't change that this is how the manhwa will be portrayed and that this is the only truth for the readers that won't read the novel. Just move on.