Yeah no

Pehyne October 12, 2023 5:55 pm

I see in the comments everyone’s talking about how she either should have killed the Duke as soon as she could or asked him to help her early on. Personally I think she should have used her poison and poisoned that whole family with her blood (wife, husband, every maid, spare no one) the night she found her sister assaulted instead of making deals and literally killing everyone but the one in the wrong. Like you could easily poison him (you were basically a maid some I’m sure you had means) or left your sister with poison to defend herself with. Like yikes you need some random man to come save you because you’re too busy thinking about romance than trying to help your sister escape. You left her there by herself with him for 3 months. Yeah.. no. Dislikable character and def no character development.

Responses
    SugarContent October 29, 2023 6:41 am

    I agree with you. But say she were to poison the whole family wouldn't she and her sister become the prime suspects? This is hypothetical.

    Pehyne October 29, 2023 8:44 am
    I agree with you. But say she were to poison the whole family wouldn't she and her sister become the prime suspects? This is hypothetical. SugarContent

    No because that’s exactly why the Duke used the poison. Because he knew with the poison’s effects he’ll never be caught.

    SugarContent October 29, 2023 10:13 am
    No because that’s exactly why the Duke used the poison. Because he knew with the poison’s effects he’ll never be caught. Pehyne

    The murder weapon is probably would never be found. But the previous noble families he killed didn't have additional members so it became unsolved murders, whereas he just adopted the girls into his family, surely it would raise suspicion?

    Pehyne October 29, 2023 10:23 am
    The murder weapon is probably would never be found. But the previous noble families he killed didn't have additional members so it became unsolved murders, whereas he just adopted the girls into his family, sur... SugarContent

    No one would think that the girls he brought in that are being abused and treated less than maids, would have access to poison. Plus it’s a poison made from blood, there wouldn’t be a way that could trace back to them.

    SugarContent October 29, 2023 10:48 am
    No one would think that the girls he brought in that are being abused and treated less than maids, would have access to poison. Plus it’s a poison made from blood, there wouldn’t be a way that could trace b... Pehyne

    Yes. But still they would be the first suspects. Remember in ML's case the female doctor or whatever was brought into investigation because she was around their house when the family was murdered. she was cleared but judging by ML's attitude I think he's not buying it. Sorry, I just finished watching a docu about murder using poison, so I'm feeling a bit hyped. Lol.

    Pehyne October 29, 2023 10:57 am
    Yes. But still they would be the first suspects. Remember in ML's case the female doctor or whatever was brought into investigation because she was around their house when the family was murdered. she was clear... SugarContent

    Even if they are suspects that doesn’t mean that they will automatically be arrested or anything. People would just be like that’s suspicious. Plus if they run away, even if caught they could just say that they were being abused and with all the chaos they figured it was perfect chance to slip away. Idk maybe because I read so much and love a good story I’m a better liar, but if it’s having your sister be assaulted and living with an abuser while being threatened or just going on the run. I know what o would do. …..anyways drop the docu I’m curious.

    SugarContent October 29, 2023 11:15 am

    Yeah. I'm 100% agree with you. I just like to think the possibilities and pretending I'm Poirot. it's a exchange hahah.
    The docu is 'Ice Cold' on netflix. Lemme tell you the case is strange. You might need vpn.