Responses
At this point, I think people are just tired of romance in the father/daughter webtoons, which is fine. But they're being weirdly agressive about their dislike of him, especially when he's not bad here or in the novel. Like you said, i dont get any red flags from him either b/c he doesnt have any. They're just projecting, honestly.
Noah actually isnt bad at all and Im not understanding the hate? He's not manipulative of Esther, and they have a good relationship. I like Noah, and i like the romance (which is obviously common in genres like this but i still eat it up).