are you guys aware that only consuming boy's love (or yaoi) especially with sex scenes, is kind of fetishizng?

peepaw August 2, 2023 2:11 am

I've tried to bring up this topic in the past, but people didn't take it good. I'm not gonna shame you guys but I hope you guys are aware if that's the only content you are consuming. The same thing goes to girl's love. I disagree with the debate that reading bl (especially those with sex scenes) is empowering women. And I know it's kind of hard to see that it is completely wrong as a few years back I was the same way with the same mentality. It is completely wrong and fetishizing to only refer to the couple in the media as seme/tops/ukes/bottoms, it seems that you don't even view the couple as human and only a sex symbol of sorts. It is completely okay to consume the content, but if it's an obsessive thing, if you make it your only personality trait, and only consuming 18+ content then you need to slow down and rethink.

I honestly didn't know if I should ask this question because people may misunderstand my intentions of posting this. I'm only posting this question as to kind of make people aware and they learn from it.

I hope what I said doesn't seem negative (like if I writing this down with a rude voice.) or derogatory.

I want to know your guy's opinions and pov's/experience's to get a better understanding.

Responses
    peepaw August 2, 2023 2:21 am

    There was a lot more I wanted to say, but my mind had a brain-fart at some point!
    If there are some things you guys want to add, go ahead! I'm happy to learn and hear !

    stan bts August 2, 2023 2:36 am

    bl gl whatever you want to call it is just a form of entertainment. who cares if its empowering people or not. honestly i could care less, and lets be honest, the issues actually affecting the lgbt community are not mitigated if you say "stop reading bl its fetishization", don't take it too seriously and just read whatever you want to read

    peepaw August 2, 2023 2:51 am
    bl gl whatever you want to call it is just a form of entertainment. who cares if its empowering people or not. honestly i could care less, and lets be honest, the issues actually affecting the lgbt community ar... stan bts

    I understand your point and agree with people should read what they want. Like if you like reading dead dove stories then go ahead! but my point wasn't to say "hey this is hurting the lgbtq community" and to make the actual issues less hurtful. I'm not saying you shouldn't consume the media at all, even I read it. Again, it's just weird to surround yourself and make your whole personality all you read is gay dudes fucking.

    Cruchy_rollers August 2, 2023 3:01 am
    I understand your point and agree with people should read what they want. Like if you like reading dead dove stories then go ahead! but my point wasn't to say "hey this is hurting the lgbtq community" and to ma... peepaw

    But isn’t that what the creators are trying to do, they make the content for people to read, and if the type of content is gay dudes fucking it’s not really a problem, both sides Benefit from it. Also, it’s not really a problem unless you try to make it one. Some people like things other people don’t. It’s a matter of opinion, morals and belief. Yes one side can be wrong or incorrect, but we’re just talking about reading gay sex. And lots of people make what they like their whole personality. Say someone really like the color pink. They can surround themselves with it and talk about it a lot but in the end it’s not hurting anyone.

    Cruchy_rollers August 2, 2023 3:02 am
    But isn’t that what the creators are trying to do, they make the content for people to read, and if the type of content is gay dudes fucking it’s not really a problem, both sides Benefit from it. Also, it�... Cruchy_rollers

    Also, how the fuck is that fetishizing

    Cruchy_rollers August 2, 2023 3:07 am
    Also, how the fuck is that fetishizing Cruchy_rollers

    One more thing, I apologize if that came off a little harsh, just trying to share my perspective

    August 2, 2023 3:09 am

    It's only fetishizing if you start projecting what fic you consume in gay people in real life.

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:10 am
    One more thing, I apologize if that came off a little harsh, just trying to share my perspective Cruchy_rollers

    Naur you’re fine, I totally understand! honestly sometime I need counter arguments to see what I need help understanding. Sometimes people tend to be stubborn and not even see the others argument and only think what they think is morally right. Thank you for sharing!

    saki August 2, 2023 3:12 am

    womp womp. women reading about 2d anime twinks fucking does no actual harm to gay men

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:15 am
    It's only fetishizing if you start projecting what fic you consume in gay people in real life.

    Exactly what I wanted to add as well! I just forgot how to word it.

    Cruchy_rollers August 2, 2023 3:16 am
    Naur you’re fine, I totally understand! honestly sometime I need counter arguments to see what I need help understanding. Sometimes people tend to be stubborn and not even see the others argument and only thi... peepaw

    Thanks for understanding! And I completely agree with you. Lots of people only stick with their side and not see where the other person is coming from. Glad we could understand each other (*^▽^*)

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:21 am
    womp womp. women reading about 2d anime twinks fucking does no actual harm to gay men saki

    Agree that in reality it doesn’t really affect people, but (like someone mentioned) if you start projecting what you read on gay couples then that’s a bit weird me thinks.

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:27 am
    Thanks for understanding! And I completely agree with you. Lots of people only stick with their side and not see where the other person is coming from. Glad we could understand each other (*^▽^*) Cruchy_rollers

    I’ve realized from your argument I should’ve worded things better and gave a different question/title Σ(  ̄□ ̄||)

    saki August 2, 2023 3:42 am
    Agree that in reality it doesn’t really affect people, but (like someone mentioned) if you start projecting what you read on gay couples then that’s a bit weird me thinks. peepaw

    Yeah, it is kinda weird but it doesn’t really matter. Majority of those people are tween girls who will grow out of it in a few years anyway… and if they don’t, who cares? It’s so trivial lol ¯_(ツ)_/¯

    azial August 2, 2023 3:43 am

    I understand. for how long I read BL I don't really have a problem with it I'm just reading it cause I've found it fun I do have boundaries when in Comes to reality I hate when fudanshi/fujoshi ship real people some of us are just so toxic defending yaoi but it's just a hobby it will become a problem if you make it a Problem

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:49 am
    I understand. for how long I read BL I don't really have a problem with it I'm just reading it cause I've found it fun I do have boundaries when in Comes to reality I hate when fudanshi/fujoshi ship real people... azial

    yes ! that's an other point, especially fudanshi's/fujoshi's ! The anime "Kiss Him, Not Me!" is a perfect example of what I was trying to say !

    Cruchy_rollers August 2, 2023 3:49 am

    Also to everyone who might have this mindset, there is no need to be ashamed in your hobby and what you read as long as it’s not something illegal(is this site illegal?) but you get what I mean

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:53 am
    Yeah, it is kinda weird but it doesn’t really matter. Majority of those people are tween girls who will grow out of it in a few years anyway… and if they don’t, who cares? It’s so trivial lol ¯_(ツ)_/... saki

    I agree. Do you know the anime "Kiss Him, Not Me!"? The protagonists is what I had in mind while typing this down. Her behavior is what I meant when I say it's weird. She's constantly projecting what she see in the media she reads/plays onto her (what i guess you can call) guy friends. I guess that's what I was hinting at lololololol

    peepaw August 2, 2023 3:57 am
    Also to everyone who might have this mindset, there is no need to be ashamed in your hobby and what you read as long as it’s not something illegal(is this site illegal?) but you get what I mean Cruchy_rollers

    I agree, my point wasn't to shame people! We're all just reading as we please (aslong it's not illegal, and yes the website is illegal lolololololo)

    Cruchy_rollers August 2, 2023 3:57 am
    Also to everyone who might have this mindset, there is no need to be ashamed in your hobby and what you read as long as it’s not something illegal(is this site illegal?) but you get what I mean Cruchy_rollers

    BUT KEEP IT A HOBBY. Don’t project it onto REAL PEOPLE!!!