SHUT YO GOOFY BADOOFY ASS UP AINT NO WAY YOU JUST SAID THAT BULLSHIT YOU LIKE RAPEY BL PLOTS NAHHH BITCH YO MOMMA DIDNT LOVE YOUINFACT? MOTHERFUCKER YOU AN ORPHAN MOTHERLESS AND FATHERLESS YOU CAME TO THE WRONG PLACE TO GIVE YOUR SHIT ASS OPINION, YOU CAN DIE ON THIS HILL SO I NEVER GOTTA SEE YO ASS AGAIN. FUCK YO STUPID ASS AND YOUR ORPHANAGE
shut the f up and leave bl lovers alone. u fool whos blinded by there own ignorance
look everyone here loves manhwa and everyone can vice there own opinion if they want and stop calling this "RAPE" do you even know what rape is?
the people like u are all blinded by your own ignorance using the term rape to cal this manhwa toxic (jk is trash ml im not saying no) and i dont see any problem with girls who like bl if none bl lovers can like yandere and dont get sh!t on for it .
then again everyone likes to judge others . but you saying "you yaoi girl who sexualize men" then wtf are u even doing here then? if u dont like bl why are u even here are u just that bored . lol
It is rape? You can be in denial all you want but even the woman who called this a "normal rape troupe" acknowledged it as rape. This manhwa is toxic but thats a seperate issue, when it comes to rape and sexual crimes thats not something you can come back from. I think thats the issue people have, this manhwa is probably gonna make it seem like rape is just a trial in a relationship that you have to overcome when its really an extreme violation of someones human rights.
About being a "yaoi girl who sexualize men" you definetly phrased it wrong. Its referring to people who fetishize homosexual relationships, usually people like this create more stigma around gay people. Its basically like the reverse of being extremely homophobic. Im biologically male or cis whatever it is and i dont necessarily like men, porn is porn to me and the drama just makes it more interesting but fetshising gay people just isnt something i do. If the only reason you read these kinds of things is because they are homosexual and homosexuality has nothing to do with you as a person, its abnormal. Usually people read BL because straight material is often misogynistic but fankly, BL's are pretty sexist and heteronormative when you think about it. You're only reading it because the character being male creates a sort of distance between you and the character making it harder to sympathise with him. Basically, its less ralatable which makes it easier to read. As long as you leave real homosexuals out of it its not the biggest deal but please do acknowledge that this is a classic rape troupe, BL really should not blur your understanding of what consent is.
Hm. What's your definition of rape then? Because all I hear is someone trying to futilely deny the fact that what the ML is doing is rape because they can't stand their precious characters having actual moral dirt on them. You might argue that this is dubcon, which is true. There are a lot of scenes here that are dubcon, but its mostly Dan just giving up on resisting against Jaekyung because he knows he won't listen to him. Seriously, can't you see Dan is being FORCED into having sex anytime and anywhere by that guy who's got no regards for other people's feelings and dignity? You might try to defend it still by saying "Oh but its a contract he gets fucked and gets the money" true but there are way too many fucking times where Jaekyung has overstepped. He hurt Dan, fucked him without his consent even when Dan kept saying "No" and "Stop". Come on. What's rape to you? Explain please because to me it's going through with fucking someone who clearly doesn't want it and forcing them to comply with it by using degrading words and sometimes even threats/blackmail-- which is what I'm seeing right now in this manhwa.
Also, although I do agree that there really wasn't any need to use 'yaoi girl' as an insult, I don't think they're referring to all 'bl lovers' as you're saying here. They're referring to the ones like the commentor who romantizes rape and toxic relationships among gay men. Plus, in the commentor's defense, though I'm not saying that its right, the commentor above them insulted them first for no reason-- and seriously, you call what they said an 'opinion'? They're just throwing insults onto someone who has a different viewpoint than them. The OP and the 1st reply were just having a peaceful thread with a bit of angry (but entirely justified) venting towards the ML which warrants no personal insulting behavior towards them. It started when the commentor you're defending insulted them personally which has no relation to the original topic at all, so I think its pretty obvious that they'll bite back.
Article 297 of South Korea's penal code defines rape as intercourse by means of “violence or intimidation.” Its funny how people are still in denial about it when Jaehyuk has threatened violence and intimidated dan or striaght up ignored him whenever he tries to stop the intercourse. It turns from sex to rape the second Jaehyuk ignores Dan's wants to stop.
i do not agree with u on it being rape.
you did make some valid points.
i agree alot of bl lovers fetishize bl and gay men.
i see an issue where that person stated that the girl should go back to her corner when technically this is her corner seens this is a bl we are talking about. i dont see the right in which others should imply others should not vice there own thoughts on something . this is a fictional manhwa hence im pretty sure the author knows what they are doing . sure doc dan said no and showed resistance. and the last chapter isnt doing any justice . although this is why i wouldnt consider it rape
1 he made a contract fully aware of knowing what he signed up for.
2 why dont he just leave if it is truly rape and abuse (dont say hes doing it for the money that would mean he choose to stay )
i do think if he does fall in love with the trash seme it would be consider stockholm syndrome , given we dont have any redemption (even with it i dont think its okay). thats wrost case scenario. or the author would bring in a new ml.
im not ignoring that it is abuse indeed but to say its rape is just wrong. or a misused term. im not useing the term "fiction " as an excuse im just stateing what it is. but many confuse fiction and reality . or they like to talk as if it is reality as if doc dan is a real human with real feels who has a choice of there own. when the gang members were going to rape dan im pretty sure that is what id consider rape rather than jk abusing and miss treating him . dont confuse abuse and rape . they are different types of abuse . note i like bl bc alot of straight manwhas are trash (most) of them are full of yandere and the fl being stalked or locked up in a basement or shes being raped by some rich ceo (but ig thats not rape seens no one gives a dam) i just stated whats popular among the people who read straight manwhs.
i agree they were being rude as well . but they was no need to say yaoi girl or
Fucking little girl making liking yaoi her entire personality.
they are others who like yaoi as well. i agree we shouldnt romantize rape. i just didnt see the need to say yaoi girl like they were implying all bl lovers like toxic rape relationships and sexualize men
I'm speechless. Not because the argument is good but because its so hypocritical and confusing that I'm rendered speechless. You somehow managed to say abuse and rape are two different things. Fine. Then Jaekyung is sexually abusing Dan. But the fact that you...oh my gosh. Okay. So when I read this in my head it was like:
Jaekyung fucks while Dan says no and stop = not rape
Other people try to fuck Dan while Dan says no and stop = oh no bad thats rape
Then at the end...really? So you're able to see rape when its straight manhwas but when its yaoi its suddenly invisible? It's suddenly more 'tame' and 'okay'? I can't its stupid I'm sorry for the word but I really can't its too ironic.
Also, what you're referring to are manhuas. Straight manhwas are usually about office romance, school life or the entertainment industry, although such plots still exists at least learn the difference...And please, don't phrase it as if the most popular yaoi manhwas aren't also about horn dog MLs fucking MCs who don't even try to or can't resist anymore. It's the same situation ya'll just refuse to see it for some reason...
Honestly I'm so over with this thread let's just end this by saying at the end of the day, we're all just readers that have our own opinions, beliefs, and morals. Just remember to not bash and insult other people for what they stand for, instead if you disagree just state your side properly.
And maybe also check yourself and what you're saying first before talking because sometimes taking a step back and looking at the whole picture instead of trying to die on the hill of your beliefs because it helps, like a lot.
(This is a general message not directed to anyone specifically)
Well to be honest i cant really stand shit with women as the main character because of how horribly written they usually are so i dont rlly know about the ones youve read but what youre doing is the same as what other people have done in trashy straight romance. Ignoring or in denial about the rape. This manhwa has a very clear depiction of rape, theres a power imbalance, Jaehyuk has been intermittently kind and Jaehyuk has threatened to use violence on dan these all create a sort of atmosphere where Dan is very intimidated and frankly, afraid. That contract dan made? Yes he knew he would have to sleep with Jaehyuk whenever Jaehyuk asked but that doesnt invalidate the fact that 90% of the time when Dan asks to stop or says wait Jaehyuk continues which turns the situation from sex to rape. In fact, Jaehyuk is extremely violent in intercourse he literally stated "you don't tear as easily anymore" as a joke. You underestimate how painful it is to be raped anally. Tears are extremely severe and often lead to an STI, i know Dan isnt real but you're refusable to acknowledge the rape in this is baffling. Havent you heard about prostitutes being raped because they wanted to stop? Dan always gets paid AFTER he is raped that means that it wouldnt cost Jaehyuk a cent to stop or give him a break. HE IGNORES HIS PLEAS BECAUSE HE DOESNT GIVE A SINGLE FUCK ABOUT CONSENT. Jeahyuk is a sociopathic narcissistic rapist who had to be told by a doctor to treat dan like a person because his body couldn't physically take it. The amount of trauma his rectum and anus has probably been subjected to is literally mindblowing but what's even crazier is that you cant see the rape when its right in front of you.
Wow... Ok so uh as the op of this comment I would say calm down. And ppl who are saying that the story doesn't shows any rape be Jk and KD. Pls go and take some psychiatric help. As a person who has been sexually abused by my own brother, ik what it feels to have no ppl around you for asking for help. Whenever I saw him, I would freeze up and couldn't do anything. It is traumatizing so pls do not joke around saying that Jk is not raping Dan. Because he is. Are you even srsly reading the story properly or not? Dan always says Jk to stop but did he ever stopped? Yes, he signed a contract which said he will be Jk's sex partner and Jk will pay him up for that too. But did Jk ever considered Dan's feelings? No, isn't that right? Honestly, being a sex partner means there needs to be consent of both the parties. But Jk does whatever he wants with Dan. And that is frustrating. Imagine if I were to do whatever I wanted with you, how would you feel? Now if anyone says this is fictional or something I'm just gonna report. Idc. There needs to be a FUCKING BOUNDARY! JUST BECAUSE IT IS FICTIONAL DOESN'T MEANS RAPE BECOMES CONSENSUAL. CUT THAT FUCKING CRAP IF YOU DONT KNOE HOW FUCK IT FEELS TO BE SEXUALLY ABUSED. IF MY MOTHER HADNT CAUGHT THAT BITCH, HE WOULD STILL HAVE BEEN SEXUALLY ABUSING ME TO THIS DAY! Characters have heart too. But Jaekyung looks the type who doesn't. He is so full of fucking crap. I don't hate Mingwa or anything but creating such characters and then having romanticism bw the victim and rapist. Is not something I like. As i said the only reason I'm reading this fuck is cuz of the art. As an aspiring artist, I love the art style this story has way too much. That reason is enough for me to read this crap. Or else I wouldn't be touching this.
no one really fights straight manhwas when ml is raping fl . or being toxic (sure some do ) but alot of people love it and is very happy when fl and ml end up together. i do not disagree its the same for most bl. or majority actually.
if u go back to the chapter where the gang members where going to rape dan youd see the difference in his expression and body language and behavior unlike with jk where dan made a contract which stated "you will have sex with me whenever i want where ever i want" doc dan fully aware of this signed . money or not it was consensual on both end of the parties. therefore not rape. without the contract and jk just forcing himself on to doc dan then it would be consider rape . do not ignore that both of them made a contract beforehand and doc dan is being paid . doc dan consensually selled his body to jk . if your gonna aruge that even with the contract it is still consider rape , then tell me what dose signing a contract to sell ones body and to give up your consent with your own free will means. im not going to call it rape i will call it abuse . there is a thin line between abuse and rape . i agree and is aware why you would consider it to be rape . if you ignore that both made a contract then yes its rape bc he didnt agree to it but surely thats not the case.
no one really fights straight manhwas when ml is raping fl . or being toxic (sure some do ) but alot of people love it and is very happy when fl and ml end up together. i do not disagree its the same for most bl. or majority actually.
if u go back to the chapter where the gang members where going to rape dan youd see the difference in his expression and body language and behavior unlike with jk where dan made a contract which stated "you will have sex with me whenever i want where ever i want" doc dan fully aware of this signed . money or not it was consensual on both end of the parties. therefore not rape. without the contract and jk just forcing himself on to doc dan then it would be consider rape . do not ignore that both of them made a contract beforehand and doc dan is being paid . doc dan consensually selled his body to jk . if your gonna aruge that even with the contract it is still consider rape , then tell me what dose signing a contract to sell ones body and to give up your consent with your own free will means. im not going to call it rape i will call it abuse . there is a thin line between abuse and rape . i agree and is aware why you would consider it to be rape . if you ignore that both made a contract then yes its rape bc he didnt agree to it but surely thats not the case.
I realllllllllyyywantwd to comment here that I don't like the plot. The only reason I'm still sticking to this even after dropping it, is cuz of the art. The art is too good to miss out tahts why I'm still here. Ah but istg if Dan falls in love with this piece of shit, I'm dropping it that day itself. Like sir there must be something wrong with you falling in love with the person who raped you. Many times. But ik, and you all know, Dan will fall in love. Jaekyung will fall in love with Dan too. After somewhat 10-30 chps, they will go out, all lovey dovey. Jaekyung will be termed as "A Tsundere". And this jinx will be removed too. Between all happiness, there will be a character who claims to be in love with Jaekyung and will hurt Dan, at that time, Jaekyung will lose it and then over.
This is so annoying. Hahahaha. I hope Jaekyung, you go and die, honey. I cannot see your face anymore. Despite you having good looks.