Have you read Color Recipe? It's a really good yaoi manga.
http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/blue_sky_complex/ or anything by Ichikawa Kei
http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/dousaibou_seibutsu/
Darenimo Aisarenai
Wonderful Life
Himegoto Asobi
Hana no Mizo Shiru (seq: Hana No Migoro Ni)
These are definitely some of my favorites that aren't too angsty but feel real -- not really school life except the last one I guess.
Sweetest thing ever
http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kouun_no_rihatsushi/
I NEED THEM URGENTLY, I NEED SOMETHING TO HEAL MY HEART
TT^TT
shoujo, Josei, Yaoi/Shounen-ai or Yuri/shoujo-ai
but pls no stupid porn manga, if sex than in a decent and rather discreet way.
I'm looking for endearing, heartwarming and heart throbbing stories that get deep under the skin.
-> I want to comprehend and understand the emotions, feel with the characters
->realistic, believable story plots, rather boring than unique but ridiculous
-> not too dramatic nut if there are tragic/messed up elements only in bits and an outweighing happy end
->Preferrably school-life or other normal life settings, bc the potential for a realistic setting is higher, but if good I don't mind fantasy or supernatural elements at all, either
Thank you!!