Judith and Luca Spoilers (+ rudy)

pinkdrink June 9, 2021 5:16 pm

Luca is not possessed (no one in this manhwa is possessed for that matter). Luca is a regressor. Luca made a wish on this thingy and he wished that everyone would be happy. That wish is what him travel back in time and that's why he acts so mature. Luca brought Judith to winterland with him bc he wanted to prevent her from dying. Judith is not possessed by anyone and she is the original Judith but she isn't aware of this yet. The memories she has are from her last life but she has always been Judith. In other words, og judith and current judith are the SAME (same soul & body). Judith never truly hated Luca and she didn't hate her sister. She loved her sister very much. (not me excusing her actions...i'm only explaining) She abused luca bc of her love for her sister. she at first blamed him for her death but she later blames winterland and ruin it (hence her trying to work with franz to try to destroy it). Luca is at first very eager to leave Judith an go with rudy (i'm not writing out his actual name) but he's later disappointed when he realizes that rudy doesn't love him. rudy is only protecting him out of a sense of duty and he then realizes that his aunt didn't actually hate him. She send him the last thing that she has of her sister (i think it was a portrait but i don't remember exactly). as you know judith dies and so does rudy (and rudy's family)...even though he overcomes all of the obstacles, he wishes everyone was happy (bc literally everyone died) and that leads to the regression. Like i said, he brought judith with him in an effort to protect her and prevent her death. He is trying to keep Judith and Rudy apart bc he doesn't want Judith to get hurt because he believes that Rudy is incapable of love.

Rudy loved judith even in the original timeline (plottwist of the century). When he was fighting off those assassins he thought about luca and how he only did this bc of a sense of duty and not out of love for luca. He then thinks about judith. He at first thought he hated her but he realizes that he doesn't hate her but in fact loves her. He fell in love with her the moment they met (love at first sight) and the same happened in this timeline (though he has yet to realize his feelings). His last thoughts before his death were of reuniting with Judith in hell.

Responses
    FujoshiSea June 9, 2021 5:21 pm

    Welp, that just made me wanna drop this lmao ( ̄∇ ̄")

    Rose June 9, 2021 5:24 pm

    Thank you for the spoilers this definitely explains a lot of what I was thinking

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 5:25 pm
    Welp, that just made me wanna drop this lmao ( ̄∇ ̄") FujoshiSea

    what about it made you wanna drop this? (it's hard for me convey my tone via writing so i'm not saying this in a mean way or anything i'm just curious which part made you wanna drop it)

    What's my name? June 9, 2021 5:26 pm

    The last sentence get me "His last thoughts before his death were of reuniting with Judith in hell." In hell Hahahahahaha lol lol lol

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 5:30 pm
    The last sentence get me "His last thoughts before his death were of reuniting with Judith in hell." In hell Hahahahahaha lol lol lol What's my name?

    right i was laughing when i found out. he has no doubts that they're both going to hell

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 5:30 pm
    Thank you for the spoilers this definitely explains a lot of what I was thinking Rose

    yw <33

    wth June 9, 2021 5:30 pm

    omigod thank you <3

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 5:32 pm
    omigod thank you <3 wth

    yw (づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ

    ag.jjtj June 9, 2021 5:32 pm
    what about it made you wanna drop this? (it's hard for me convey my tone via writing so i'm not saying this in a mean way or anything i'm just curious which part made you wanna drop it) pinkdrink

    Idk about her, (not maybe wanna drop it but kinda ruined it for me) the love at first sight thing. I don’t believe that stuff at all and I really hate when they make characters fall in love with a first glance. It’s so unrealistic. Especially for someone as distant to people as him, too cheesy and cliche

    FujoshiSea June 9, 2021 5:32 pm
    what about it made you wanna drop this? (it's hard for me convey my tone via writing so i'm not saying this in a mean way or anything i'm just curious which part made you wanna drop it) pinkdrink

    Idkkkk lol I guess I just give up on stories where I know whats going to happen. I had my thoughts on Luca and turns out that my theory about him was correct. I'll stick a around for a while til they get to the end though.(づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ

    FujoshiSea June 9, 2021 5:35 pm
    Idk about her, (not maybe wanna drop it but kinda ruined it for me) the love at first sight thing. I don’t believe that stuff at all and I really hate when they make characters fall in love with a first glanc... ag.jjtj

    That too lol. I forgot about that

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 5:37 pm
    Idk about her, (not maybe wanna drop it but kinda ruined it for me) the love at first sight thing. I don’t believe that stuff at all and I really hate when they make characters fall in love with a first glanc... ag.jjtj

    yeah i get that. I would've liked it better if he liked her bc he understood her feelings due to his childhood (or something along those lines ya know) but i rlly hate the love at first sight trope. imo their feelings for each other seemed to be really shallow. I remember he asked her what she loved about him and she said his face....i-.....that mixed in with the love at first sight thing just..ick. There was also this scene towards the end where Franz and Rudy were fighting and Franz shot Judith (right before Rudy shot and killed Franz) and then she fell into a coma. Rudy tried to commit suc!cide after that and everyone had to talk him out of it. She woke up 3 days later but idk their feelings just seem really shallow. I'm still gonna read this but some things are just hella disappointing

    Potchie June 9, 2021 5:54 pm
    Welp, that just made me wanna drop this lmao ( ̄∇ ̄") FujoshiSea

    Noo.. don't drop it. There's still lots of plot twists for u hahaha.

    Pandora's_Breaker June 9, 2021 6:03 pm

    I knew it!! I had a feeling luca had memories since there are hints like exm. Chapter 8 page 12, ch.9 pg.61, & ch.11 pg. 24 at the end possible foreshadowing??

    shy June 9, 2021 6:32 pm

    IN HELL?? LMAOOOO WHAAATT

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 6:36 pm
    IN HELL?? LMAOOOO WHAAATT shy

    i mean he's self aware. He knows that him and judith have both done some questionable things (her more than him) but it's still really funny

    03♡ June 9, 2021 6:40 pm

    Ok wow that was a major spoiler but it answered all of my questions, still gonna stick around tho cuz that sounds interesting

    pinkdrink June 9, 2021 7:25 pm
    Ok wow that was a major spoiler but it answered all of my questions, still gonna stick around tho cuz that sounds interesting 03♡

    same. some parts disappointed me but it's interesting overall so i'm going to continue reading it.

    Yona June 9, 2021 7:54 pm

    Thank you! Now im more excited to read this!!

    ag.jjtj June 10, 2021 8:47 am
    yeah i get that. I would've liked it better if he liked her bc he understood her feelings due to his childhood (or something along those lines ya know) but i rlly hate the love at first sight trope. imo their f... pinkdrink

    That just seems like story is very undeveloped. It seems like author got lazy with their relationship and feelings, so they did the most cliche into an extreme and called it a good love story. I love it changes a bit in webtoon