Responses
AHAHAHAHAH SAME HERE!!! Even though she doesn´t read it (she´s kinda opening to this new world?) She was all: Duuuude there's such a cospiracy and all that
I alway thought this theory was totally whack, until I decided to look at the evidence. It would also explain "Ciels" change in personailty to Lizzy who remembered him as positive and always smiling in the past.
Ok, this may be somewhat considered a spoiler or maybe not but just in case:
IF YOU HADN'T READ THE MANGA DON'T READ THIS.
Or do it if you don't care but I've warned you. I just seek answers.
It has been hinted that Ciel had a brother and some say it was a twin, anyway, I was rereading this and got to the wolf and witch part, but well when Ciel gets ''sick' and has his mental-breakdown he start remembering things from when he was captive and talks about someone who was with him http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroshitsuji/an/v18/c090/1.html/pg-16/ buuuuut I don't think the one shown is Ciel... and then he has that internal dialog with 'himself'' but the other doesn't have the mark of the pact between Ciel & Sebastian http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroshitsuji/an/v18/c093/pg-11/ and then at last we got this http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroshitsuji/an/v18/c095/pg-5/ which makes you think he talks about himself sacrificing his soul but what if it isn't........ what if it's the other, the real Ciel......
And maybe Undertaker (most probably) knows all....sooo is confusing and could be wrong but since that ''he may had a twin theory'' exists well it could be