°Incest Confusion Survey

Thank you for replying to my survey. I respect your answer

For me
- not alright if its blood related
- if its blood related, even half, nope. But i think cousin is okay for me.
- yup, its fine for me
- in my opinion, i read manga just for fun, so even if the manga might contain immoral stuff, i know its fiction and doesn't change my morals, for example, yaoi mostly contains lots of rape, i might ship the couple, the sex scene might be hot, but thats fiction, doesn't mean i would approved their behaviour if its in real life, the same with incest yaoi. This depends on the reader, as for me, i would take example from the good stuff, and ignore the bad.
- my habit is, i read the tag and review before i start any manga. As i said earlier, blood related x, non blood related /. BUT if i accidentally read the blood related, honestly i would feel a bit awkward and disgust if its forced, but if its with consent, i will ship them and maybe think the sex might be hot.
Which is, idc about the manga moral value, but if i can avoid the tag i dislike, i would avoid it, but if i cant, i dont think too much about it and move on, doesn't effect my real life moral value.

Thank you for replying. I respect your answer

Well I'm curious bout how other saw this too......


But as for me as long it not blood related it fine I guess ┑(￣Д ￣)┍. Same father different mom is a no. Different father same mom is a BIG NO.
Well it give me a huge mixed feeling after reading it. Depends on how the story goes. If it some fucked up relationship yeah I might bleach nah brain up. Love and hate, that one make me feel a bit emotionally exhausted but yeah it fine because they not blood related.

I respect that

Thank you for this honest response Marshmallow. Your insights will truly help my study. Goodnight xoxo

no
no
no(unless the kids were already together before the parents, but even then its ehhhh)
yes
never finished one(im very close with all of my step & blood siblings so incest in general triggers tf out of me).

Thank you lord. Someone mentioned 'Love or Hate'. We have the same thoughts of the whole journey of this manhwa. It's emotionally exhausting especially the ch. 97. By the way, thank you foe your honest response.

(⌒▽⌒)

I actually like that you brought up this question cause reading incestuous books are kinda like my guilty pleasure... also filipino ka?

oh man this is a little hard but is supposed to be simple but is still hard? anyways here are my answers.

1. i think whatever plot the author wanted their story to have is fine. that is called freedom or liberty depending on their definitions that i am too lazy to check. if they want to write about incest, well i won't be the one to tell them not to do it. if they want to write about a cat enjoying the sun in the grass, still won't be the one to tell them not to. i believe that we should stop taking responsibilities away from people. i believe that if a 14 years old (which is considered a somewhat young age right?) reads about rape in a story and comes to the conclusion that rape is ok or normal, it isn't only the story/author's fault, there was already something wrong with the person, or their education, or the way they process things. at some point humans are able to think by themselves and have a clear idea of what's right and wrong no matter what they read or watch or come across in their lives. in my opinion.

2. the moment you are related by blood, be it half, full, cousin or anything closer than maybe, great-great-great-grandparents generation, it is not just "alright/fine", because it isn't in real life.

3. if you are not blood related but maybe grew up together or something like that, it is completely fine to me. it's like saying to 2 childhood friends they are not allowed to have feelings for the other because they grew "as" siblings. but they are not actually related. things in their life just made it so they met when they were little, it does not matter whether they met when they were 1 week old or 25 years old, it is alright.

4. i believe these kind of mangas are allowed to be out there. that is called freedom, liberty to create whatever you want to and freedom to read whatever you want to. but i think a responsibility comes with creating and/or reading this kind of stories. the responsibility to not bring it into "real life". responsibility to not make it seem like, because you read it in a fictional story and you liked it, it is now normal for you to project it on real life people. responsibility to understand that no, sexual relationships between siblings are not normal and that scientifically speaking, two people of opposite genders who share the same blood have a much higher chance of passing on recessive diseases to their children. so you can understand that relationships between people sharing the same blood are not meant to be.
so i dont think that we should label them as immoral or smth like that, we just have to make sure that people truly understand where the fictional world ends and where the real one begins. what you read/do in private should not be the business of other people as long as your activity does not harm others in any way. (i used harm for a lack of better word, wish something would come to mind right now, harm does not feel like the best choice but oh well)

5. i don't think much when i read this kind of stories. maybe the fact that it is a taboo and prohibited subject makes it "appealing", or "exciting" or "interesting" to read but reading such stories won't keep me up at night nor will it make me love the concept of reading them. if i come across an incest story, might read it if i'm feeling it, i'll enjoy whatever there is to enjoy in the story, finish it and move on. pretty simple.

hope my answer is okay, i actually wrote that at 3am so lets hope i didn't write too much bs (づ￣ ³￣)づ

oh! i liked what you said! yup yup yup i mostly share that opinion

Opo, hilaw na pinoy po.

The effort of this honest response is just 100%. Your point will be very helpful for my case study. Thank you very much and I hope we can be mutual

happy if it helped! if it's a study, will you get marked? i hope you get a good grade (≧∀≦) of course! with pleasure :))

aww sis, i love your opinion too, i also believe mangaka have their right to draw anything they love, we as a reader should know which is bad or good, which is real and fiction.

haha you kinda polite and cute. have a great day hirose chan