Bruuuuh

Honey-senpai April 28, 2021 5:42 pm

Why are they cutting out so much from the novel?! I actually wanted to see the hospital scenes when Thomas woke up and thought about how much he respected Jin-Woo and when Jin-Woo visited Jin-Ho before they went to the Night of the Hunters. The manhwa is rushing too much ╥﹏╥

Responses
    juneleei April 28, 2021 5:45 pm

    i also thought that lol but atleast they didn't skipped the important parts

    Kaye April 28, 2021 5:49 pm

    Oh thats why i feel that there is something missing

    Juliaprime April 28, 2021 5:52 pm

    Maybe they cutting the extra part so the story in manhaw wont be long like the novel

    Honey-senpai April 28, 2021 7:58 pm
    Maybe they cutting the extra part so the story in manhaw wont be long like the novel Juliaprime

    But it was better in the novel, details matter, especially Thomas' scene, reading this chapter just made Thomas almost out of character because manhwa readers don't know his thought process that the novel showed in the hospital scene when he wakes up. In that scene, he thought about how he lost and it was humbling for him to be put in a hospital bed. He was in awe and respect of Jin-Woo's strength. When he finds out there were no other casualties other than Hwang Dong-Su, he was shocked and confused and couldn't stop questioning why the Scavenger Guild wasn't killed. I'm really disappointed how much the manhwa is cutting out, and they're ALL good parts of the novel. I'm sad to say it but season two is really down-graded compared to season 1. I still love it and will keep reading it but I'm glad I read the novel beforehand for context that's not even included in the manhwa.

    Juliaprime April 28, 2021 8:46 pm
    But it was better in the novel, details matter, especially Thomas' scene, reading this chapter just made Thomas almost out of character because manhwa readers don't know his thought process that the novel showe... Honey-senpai

    It's manwha or maybe it was the writer choice... The illustrationist just sometimes following the lead of the higher ups.

    Juliaprime April 28, 2021 8:48 pm
    But it was better in the novel, details matter, especially Thomas' scene, reading this chapter just made Thomas almost out of character because manhwa readers don't know his thought process that the novel showe... Honey-senpai

    And I was thinking maybe they want the manwha version is pure "action" and less "emotional or sentimental" since that's how it start from the beginning

    juneleei April 29, 2021 2:34 am
    But it was better in the novel, details matter, especially Thomas' scene, reading this chapter just made Thomas almost out of character because manhwa readers don't know his thought process that the novel showe... Honey-senpai

    i understand that part even me was kind of disappointed in the part of second encounter of jinwoo to the double gate in the novel it was more than that but this type of cutting off is not that new, manhwa is really lacking deep emotions as it was portrayed in illustrations unlike the novels

    Honey-senpai April 29, 2021 11:01 am
    And I was thinking maybe they want the manwha version is pure "action" and less "emotional or sentimental" since that's how it start from the beginning Juliaprime

    Really? Season 1 definitely had more emotional depth, even Jin-Woo seemed to have more emotions than he does in season 2. He's so stoic and his pov is a lot more limited than what it used to be. The manhwa is so abrupt with the tone shift, that it's almost unnatural.

    Honey-senpai April 29, 2021 11:07 am
    i understand that part even me was kind of disappointed in the part of second encounter of jinwoo to the double gate in the novel it was more than that but this type of cutting off is not that new, manhwa is re... juneleei

    I'm more frustrated because of how faithful to the novel the manhwa was in season 1 compared to season 2. They've only really cut out more and more scenes after starting season 2. It makes me more worried for other manhwas adapted from novels, like another one I'm reading Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint that's really accurate to the novel right now but might not be later ┗( T﹏T )┛

    juneleei April 29, 2021 11:47 am
    I'm more frustrated because of how faithful to the novel the manhwa was in season 1 compared to season 2. They've only really cut out more and more scenes after starting season 2. It makes me more worried for o... Honey-senpai

    that is so true bruh