
I feel bad for the brothers too, from their perspective they may be able to renew the relationship. When they were kids, they were afraid of angering the father and getting shunned as well. They never learned how to express affection from their father. Now that they can stand up for themselves and are missing their sister they realized that they should act on it.
However after spending 400 years as a reluctant killing machine with no free will there should be no way for her to forgive them. The mental torture she went through is simply too much. It is sad. But the father is still a fucking ass.

but if they want to be forgiven they really have to make a huge effort to be forgiven I'm not sure about it since Charlize seems to traumatized to feel anything anymore charlize really didn't deserve all of that but the father tho he knew what he was doing wrong he has no common sense he could go eat shit he made a little progress in the novel but no I'm not forgiving a piece of shit
I kinda
Jus a little
Feel bad for the youngest brother
Not trying to trauma dump here but : being in an abusive household where youll do whatever and say whatever to be treated properly and to basically get by, i understand why the bro learned to be that way from the dad and older bro, like if youve seen how cold and horrible people can be youll do whatever you can to get by,
And regarding the flowers i actually cried, cause he understood his wrongs and wasnt forcing her to stay in the family he just wanted to give her flowers for her birthday, he didn't know what would happen and that made me cry.
My younger sister reminds me of him so much, she was horrible towards me but ut was just for her to get by and for her to not be ostracized and looking back on it i get why she did that, i geuss thats kinda why i feel a little bad for the younger bro
So yh sorry if i pissed anyone of or if im trauma dumping not the intention jus tried to shed lit on the situation cause id seen a couple comments saying the bro should die and shi. ╥﹏╥ please dont be angry with me