I can't understand why

Annie March 19, 2016 1:46 am

I can't understand why shingo broke up with him if still loves him????????

Responses
    frazzleyama March 19, 2016 2:40 am

    would you break up with your bf if he gave you reasons to think he was cheating on you?

    yelloheh March 19, 2016 7:46 am
    would you break up with your bf if he gave you reasons to think he was cheating on you? frazzleyama

    Except that Shingo never mention Angelo's scent in the breaking. He only told that Keichi lost scent and Shingo jump to the conclusion that Keichi lost interest in him. He NEVER give Keichi a reason nor he let him explain.
    I'm really sure that Keichi never cheat on Shingo, even if I don't get why he follow Angel. I'm a little pissed to see everybody put the blame on Keichi. I don't say that he's pure and innocent but for me he's not the villain everybody made.

    mrsgdragonssi March 19, 2016 8:54 am

    it's because Shingo thought he was saving himself from more heartbreak if he decided to stay with him. He was used to being abandoned and he wouldn't be able to take it if Keiichi abandons him as well :(

    frazzleyama March 19, 2016 11:41 am
    Except that Shingo never mention Angelo's scent in the breaking. He only told that Keichi lost scent and Shingo jump to the conclusion that Keichi lost interest in him. He NEVER give Keichi a reason nor he let ... yelloheh

    "i'm really sure that keiichi never cheat on shingo" i'm pretty sure if you kiss someone who's not your partner then you're cheating ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

    Sunika March 19, 2016 12:03 pm
    Except that Shingo never mention Angelo's scent in the breaking. He only told that Keichi lost scent and Shingo jump to the conclusion that Keichi lost interest in him. He NEVER give Keichi a reason nor he let ... yelloheh

    He's not that we see him as a "villain" but his behavior latley. We are more disappointed in him i guess. He did a lot of things that we did not expect him to do. Keiichi didn't even tryied to explain. I know that Shingo has his fault a little but this time, Keiichi messed up pretty bad. His behavior, Angelo, him going to another country... He told that he smelt someone else on him. And Keiichi brush him off.

    Sunika March 19, 2016 12:05 pm
    it's because Shingo thought he was saving himself from more heartbreak if he decided to stay with him. He was used to being abandoned and he wouldn't be able to take it if Keiichi abandons him as well :( mrsgdragonssi

    Yeah and anyone will belive that will be abandoned after Keiichi behavior, not to mantion that he practically leaved him behind when he decided to leave without him.

    mrsgdragonssi March 19, 2016 1:17 pm

    well, Shingo is the one who broke Keiichi's heart first. I do not think Keiichi wanted to end their relationship and abandon Shingo, but the latter was the one who wanted to break up. Shingo wanted to save his ass from the heartbreak, never realizing this method was more painful for the both of them. Still, I think both of them are at fault here and proper communication is the key to solve this.

    yelloheh March 19, 2016 1:47 pm
    "i'm really sure that keiichi never cheat on shingo" i'm pretty sure if you kiss someone who's not your partner then you're cheating ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭ frazzleyama

    We don't know if they kiss. Keichi just mentioned that they were together all night long and we saw Angelo trying to kiss Keichi but we don't see the scene. Angelo's scent on Keichi is the result of their promiscuity. Angelo seems to be a problematic character and Keichi who is very arrogant is very quiet toward him and that means Angelo is someone he don't treat lightly. We just don't know why...

    frazzleyama March 19, 2016 1:52 pm
    well, Shingo is the one who broke Keiichi's heart first. I do not think Keiichi wanted to end their relationship and abandon Shingo, but the latter was the one who wanted to break up. Shingo wanted to save his ... mrsgdragonssi

    if we're talking about breaking hearts then i'm pretty sure it was keiichi. remember when shingo confessed to him and keiichi told him to go home? keiichi then told shingo he wanted to to go back to being fuck buddies and said that they shouldn't kiss either. shingo suffered a lot because of that but keiichi didn't care as long as they had sex. once he saw shingo and hasumi interacting he got jealous and probably got the "if i can't have him then no one else can." mindset. so honestly keiichi just got a taste of his own medicine ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭

    frazzleyama March 19, 2016 2:43 pm
    We don't know if they kiss. Keichi just mentioned that they were together all night long and we saw Angelo trying to kiss Keichi but we don't see the scene. Angelo's scent on Keichi is the result of their promi... yelloheh

    "we don't know if they kiss" uh yes they did and keiichi did nothing to stop angelo from kissing him so he cheated on shingo. read the manga again.

    Sunika March 19, 2016 3:29 pm
    "we don't know if they kiss" uh yes they did and keiichi did nothing to stop angelo from kissing him so he cheated on shingo. read the manga again. frazzleyama

    He could turn his head when Shingo wanted to kiss him, but he couldn't do the same with Angelo? No excuse.

    frazzleyama March 19, 2016 5:41 pm
    He could turn his head when Shingo wanted to kiss him, but he couldn't do the same with Angelo? No excuse. Sunika

    *applauds* thank you for not having any of keiichi's bs

    yelloheh March 19, 2016 7:10 pm
    "we don't know if they kiss" uh yes they did and keiichi did nothing to stop angelo from kissing him so he cheated on shingo. read the manga again. frazzleyama

    I'm sorry but no, we don't see them kiss. Nevermind, we are not agree. We just have to wait next update to see if we get an answer and who between us were wrong or right :-)

    Sunika March 19, 2016 7:19 pm
    I'm sorry but no, we don't see them kiss. Nevermind, we are not agree. We just have to wait next update to see if we get an answer and who between us were wrong or right :-) yelloheh

    Yes we see them kiss.
    http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroneko_kareshi_no_afurekata/mf/v01/c005/5/
    Angelo is kissing him!

    Sunika March 19, 2016 7:28 pm
    I'm sorry but no, we don't see them kiss. Nevermind, we are not agree. We just have to wait next update to see if we get an answer and who between us were wrong or right :-) yelloheh

    Twice actualy.... here is another page
    http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroneko_kareshi_no_afurekata/mf/06b9f5e5b4e21b67/Vol1_Ch3/pg-13/
    And why is Keiichi leting him? He with Shingo he knew how to turn his head? Why he didn't do the same with Angelo. Leting happen is the same as participating.
    http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroneko_kareshi_no_afurekata/mf/v01/c005/16/
    I really don't understand how the next chapter will make this 2 pages dissapear.

    mrsgdragonssi March 19, 2016 8:11 pm
    if we're talking about breaking hearts then i'm pretty sure it was keiichi. remember when shingo confessed to him and keiichi told him to go home? keiichi then told shingo he wanted to to go back to being fuck ... frazzleyama

    uh no. as far as I can remember what happened back then was also a misunderstanding, Keiichi was pretty pissed because Shingo didn't listen to what he says (No other people touching him, Keiichi would never abandon Shingo etc). It led to him interpreting that Shingo never took their relationship seriously and that Shingo was afraid of beginnings because he always chooses endings as a premise. So he thought being straight-out fuck buddies would be a lot better than having a relationship with him. (But we all know how wrong his conclusion was that time but seriously, it was the way that relationship was headed anyway and I was glad they cleared that misunderstanding).

    Keiichi is not getting his own taste of medicine lol if anything I think Shingo still hasn't grown out of his insecurities and now it's coming back to bite his ass (Keiichi is pretty much indifferent with him now when he usually is the one who chases after him)

    Sunika March 19, 2016 8:29 pm
    uh no. as far as I can remember what happened back then was also a misunderstanding, Keiichi was pretty pissed because Shingo didn't listen to what he says (No other people touching him, Keiichi would never aba... mrsgdragonssi

    Yeah they worked out that misunderstanding. I don't think is indiferent, true he behaved like an ass and do a lot of unnecessary things that hurt Shingo the most in this vol.
    But Keiichi is having insecurities as well. I think he needed Shingo to be more posesive.
    But this time is was not a misunderstanding, Keiichi did give Shingo lot of reasons to to unsure.

    yelloheh March 19, 2016 9:08 pm
    Yes we see them kiss.http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/kuroneko_kareshi_no_afurekata/mf/v01/c005/5/Angelo is kissing him! Sunika

    No sorry, we don't see it. They are very very very close but I don't see their lips touching. Maybe at the last moment he turned his head.
    BUT, I admit that he turned his head while Shingo try to kiss him so maybe he's guilty or there's something he's not proud about. So maybe a kiss with Angelo or maybe the fact that he know he has to lie or hide something to Shingo and he feel guilty because he fears the consequences. This story really bother me. That gives me headache !

    Sunika March 19, 2016 10:08 pm

    Tell me about it! :)) I think is the first time a story had me so worked out:)))
    And i agree with you that he felt guilty, that's why he turned his head. My point was that he can turn his head if he wants. And yes in one pic they are close, but in the other one they are clearly kissing.
    http://www.mangago.zone/read-manga/kuroneko_kareshi_no_afurekata/mf/v01/c005/5/
    In this one, scroll down a little the pic and you will see. I insisting with this because well.. i was like "huh? they are clearly kissing, what is he/she talking" and i actualy gone back to look. :))) twice. I know, i know. It's Keiichi we are talking and i never expected to do such a thing. I just hope he has a good explanation. I'm very disappointed. But well i still have hope in him.

    mrsgdragonssi March 20, 2016 2:14 am
    Yeah they worked out that misunderstanding. I don't think is indiferent, true he behaved like an ass and do a lot of unnecessary things that hurt Shingo the most in this vol. But Keiichi is having insecurities ... Sunika

    lol I don't really think Keiichi doesn't love Shingo anymore, in fact he still loves him very, very much so he is hurting too. He does have his insecurities, a lot of them stemming down from Shingo's false statements. This situation is a misunderstanding IMO. Keiichi became arrogant, forgetting to consider Shingo's past insecurities. Shingo is still damn unsure and thinks he would still be abandoned in the end. I do hope they sort this thing out right now and communicate properly because if they don't (and we only get one steamy sex to solve the problem), this misunderstanding would still reoccur in the future. I do enjoy the steamy scenes but I learned to care deeply for these characters and would genuinely wish for their happiness. :)