damn dude that is some GOOD deduction skills
Haha thank you! (=・ω・=)
(though I do tend to over analyse, so I could be reading things totally wrong ╮(￣▽￣)╭) but anyways I'll probably update this with more evidence as the story progresses!
eventhough this is just a theory i cant help but feel like crying wth if this is what happened and seunyul cheated on ran with her half sister, thats gonna be so sad i hope he fucks off
Ikr, low key hoping I'm wrong ╥﹏╥
I think the theory on how the ghost is the brother makes so much sense because if ghost is “Goyo” they are the same soul but just from different time so it makes sense that ghost can’t use his “own” body. However ghost is able to use “Seunyul” because they are twins and have the same body. That also make the theory that ghost’s memories are him watching Seunyul because they are family and are always together. Also in the memories it only shows both twins together when they are children but not in any other older memories the ghost remembers so that also add more evidence to that theory.
Ooh good catch! That makes a lot of sense!
I think the ghost is goyo, but ran married seunyul in the future and something bad happened, so goyo came back to change that because:
1) someone mentioned hair parting is the same for both, and he could have died his hair back to black
2) his personality is more similar, and even ran said ghost 'seunyul' doesn't seem like seunyul
3) ghost doesn't remember his name, so it could be either of them
4) goyo does seem uncomfortable (maybe subconsciously jealous idk) of the two in the present even, and ghost's jealousy is very similar
4) the memories look like they are being viewed by a third person- perhaps ran actually married seunyul and goyo liked her too so he just looked at the two all the time and that's why he had memories in the pov of someone looking at them?
5) that scene of ran attempting to drown (?) may be why he came back to the past- she might have married seunyul but was unhappy, so goyo came back to change it
6) introduction of joy- I think maybe seunyul cheated on ran with joy or something happened with her that made ran want to end her life in ghost's dream, even right now it seems like there is something between them (she just gives me bad vibes lmao)
7) also in that same nightmare, ghost was not saying sorry, so I think we can assume he wasn't the cause of her attempted suicide; makes me believe once again that it was goyo who liked her secretly and came back in the past to save her this time