Responses
I feel like Claude hating athy forever is very unlikely (even if black magic is involved) cause they already have a very strong bond.
Claude can forget her over and over again but that bond will never vanish
Also that scene was the original athanasia's future not athy's, athy already changed the future by winning claude's affection
Why do I have a feeling that once Claude woke up, he still hate athy cuz remember what happened in the beginning of the story? Athy said "do I need to be Jennette for you to love me? " [I can't really remember] then Claude replied coldly "theirs never been a time i treat you as a daughter" (Sorry guys I can't remember) then athy cried and some people staying that athy will get EXECUTED