Responses
I agree mostly. I think they chose transmigration as a simple way to give her the knowledge of the future but it may have been better to have either gone the route of reincarnated into her own body (going back and correcting her own past) or magic premonition dream. She's magic anyway so either would work. They're all tropes but this one does feel the least suited to the character.
I really like this story so far.
The tsundere MC is hilarious and I love the relationship and interactions between the characters.
I find it a bit unnecessary to have made Celeste a reincarnator, though. She acts like the queen and not at all as a "regular 20 year old Korean woman".
I mean, I get that she's been a witch 10 times longer and that could've altered her personality, but then shouldn't her memories of her time in our world also have faded?
She talks like she was reincarnated last week, but acts like she was native to her current world, life and body.
Imo it seemed like a pointless attempt of following the isekai/reincarnated-into-a-novel trope. It clashes with the otherwise brilliant concept of the MC's personality and her knowledge of the plot could've been explained in a much better way.
It is a fantasy world, after all. And she's a witch. Prophetic dreams, magic crystal balls, enchanted books; the author could've chosen countless other options that do not involve reincarnation...
It still like it though, so I'll try to overlook that minor annoying detail and enjoy the story regardless.