beta
Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6.5 - (meh)
FL Attractiveness: 5
ML Character: 7
ML Attractiveness: 6.5
Summary: FL is a prominent knight captain, and ML is chasing her by joining her knight squadron as her subordinate.
Comment: I cannot for the life of me bring myself to care about the actual plot points.
Tier: C
Plot: 8.5
Art Style: 4
Slowish Pace | Angst
FL Character: 8
FL Attractiveness: 3
Summary: FL is a "chosen one" summoned into a "villainess"'s body, has the power to stave off the madness of many male characters. [Spoilers:] ML(?) is a fucking controlling asshole imprisoning her.
Comment: Subverted my expectations, good on them. Artstyle is still ass though.
Tier: C
Plot: 8
Art Style: 4
Slowish Pace | ??
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 4
ML Character: 6
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is from a fallen noble family, only studying at the academy due to a scholarship for her grades. Missing an exam made her lose the scholarship so ML funds her tuition to get her to stay, but she has to tutor him.
Comment: N/A
Tier: C-
Plot: 5
Art Style: 7
Slowish Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5 - (generic child FL)
Summary: FL is a child from a collateral branch of the family but is adopted by the heir. Instantly recognised as helpful. Meets other children throughout the plot that are future MLs.
Comment: Very generic, don't really care about the plot nor the characters
Tier: C-
Plot: 7
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | ???
FL Character: 3
FL Attractiveness: 5
ML Character: 2
ML Attractiveness: 4
Summary: FL is a concubine of the emperor and accidentally catches his attention. [Spoilers:] ML deceives her a pretends to be a servant.
Comment: Just about every other side character has a more interesting plot than the MCs. I'd rather read from their perspective. Neither FL nor ML are compelling at all. Reading for the surrounding plot. Title doesn't really fit.
Tier: C-
Plot: 6
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 4
Summary: FL is a noble child, in her past life she was successful at cultivating rice, and now bringing rice into this world is basically her whole purpose.
Comment: I really do not care for any of these characters nor plot points. I actually hate the rabbit so fucking much they try to portray him as cute but its so damn ugly.
Tier: C-
Plot: 8
Art Style: 5
Slow Pace | ???
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 4
ML Character: 3
ML Attractiveness: 4
Summary: FL's family was persecuted and ML basically saved her. [Spoiler:] fucky wucky time travelling and spirit powers.
Comment: Cool ideas, meh execution. Had potential, what a shame.
Tier: C-
Plot: 7
Art Style: 4
Slow Pace | Both Angst & Fluff
FL Character: 6
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 5
ML Attractiveness: 3
Summary: FL reincarnates as a villainess married to a husband that does not like her. [Spoilers:] The villainess has a huge secret she's been hiding and FL is discovering it bit by bit.
Comment: That title is a fucking lie, he is not handsome. At least it has a somewhat interesting plot
Tier: C-
Plot: 7
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | ??
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 5
ML Attractiveness: 7
Summary: FL is OG villainess, born to a poor family, now trying to make money. ML is OG villain who now sees money making opportunities in her. OG ML is her childhood friend and very clingy to her. OG FL is now mad because OG ML wants to still be close with FL.
Comment: Dynamics between the characters is kind of interesting. But story is still kinda generic.
Messages