darker reincarnation

this one's a doozy

Born into a villain family, but is actually affected by the cruel nature of her family structure
("I played the role of the adopted daughter too well" is within a villain family, but is still closer to the mushy side. Still like that one too though)

bigtime trauma and an eating disorder. Our girl is a strong independent woman, but maybe she doesn't have to be. Maybe people are meant to lean on each other and heal.

A popular one! Certainly more desperate than most, with relationships that are too broken to become fluffy doting ones like in many dating sim villainess stories. There's heaviness and remorse can hit like sweetness in that painful way.