Real Honest Romance Fantasy Reviews

being a big fan of a genre that is mostly wish fulfillment is suffering when u are a Story Enjoyer like myself. however i am also a big fan of being a hater. this is my Real Honest Otome Isekai (and other romance fantasy genres) Diary.

things i consider:
 is there an underlying theme to the work?
 do the characters undergo change?
 is the male lead simply an accessory purse chihuahua to the female lead?
 is the translation good? is the artstyle nice?
 etc etc
All(59) / manga(59)

Kill the Villainess

 9.5(448 voted)
Complete
Author(s): Haegi,Your april
Genre(s): Drama / Harem / Josei / Webtoons / Romance / Shoujo

3/5

pros/
+ subverts so many villainess expectations. for one thing, she’s willing to die to go back to her world
+ her character design… shez so beautiful
+ compelling dynamic between heroine and villainess

cons/
+ way too many silly magic sideplots that bogged up the story and the tone
+ romance was bland
+ really interesting concept, but bland execution lol

09 10,2023

The Way That Knight Lives As a Lady

 9.3(171 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Sung Hyerim,Seong hye-rim,Seong Hyeon
Genre(s): Fantasy / Romance / Webtoons

3/5

pros/
+ interesting dynamic between the two leads
+ politics are more subtle than other ois
+ second ml sucks in a way that makes me so angry LOL i feel like it takes talent to make me dislike a chara that much

cons/
+ more of a personal gripe but it kinda sucks she used to be a great warrior but cannot fight in her second life
+ translation dips in quality :(

09 10,2023

Remarried Empress

 9.6(444 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Alphatart , Sumpul
Genre(s): Romance / Webtoons

3/5

pros/
+ genuinely like the emperor’s character. he has selfish motives and his chara arc was interesting… it was such a choice for him to have cheated on main chara bc he had a superiority complex towards her

cons/
+ idk why the story continued after empress divorced her husband lol it lost all its tension afterwards
+ romance was cute at the beginning but got so bland and the ml is boring
+ translation quality dipped so bad

09 10,2023

Bring the Love

 9.6(1041 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): 제스트쿄 (zestkyō)
Genre(s): Comedy / Drama / Historical / Romance / Webtoons

3/5

pros/
+ so cute! a sensible, slowburn love between two strong people
+ politics were reasonable and not over the top; family duties felt so grounded and so the stakes felt real

cons/
+ not fond of the art style
+ why is this set in the real world LOL
+ a point taken off because the sexy masc sister queerbaited me for real. why did they pair her off with a man… it makes me sick to my stomach.

09 10,2023

I'll Be The Matriarch In This Life

 9.8(561 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Kim Roah, Ant Studio,Gammon
Genre(s): Webtoons / Drama / Fantasy / Historical / Romance

3/5

pros/
+ schemes are interesting and entertaining
+ art is so beautiful and i like the fashion and accessories! style feels consistent

cons/
+ 120 chapters of child arc with no end in sight is a little crazy
+ ml has zero personality and is definitely a purse chihuahua
+ how schemes are resolved r a little repetitive lol

09 10,2023

Resetting Lady

 9.2(1049 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): Webtoons / Drama / Fantasy / Psychological / Romance / Tragedy

4/5

pros/
+ i’m a real sucker for unhinged protags and horror so… this is perfectly up my alley
+ i love the mystery unfolding.. pacing is immaculate
+ main character is genuinely so beautiful and i love the art style!!
+ such a tense romantic relationship lol

cons/
+ can get a lil melodramatic at times; some plot points feel a lil over the top LOL

09 10,2023

Cinderella Wasn't Me

 9.4(211 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): Webtoons / Josei / Fantasy /

1/5

pros/
+ love main chara’s design!

cons/
+ the plot feels like it was created by elementary students roleplaying a fantasy adventure at the playground. it’s so melodramatic; everyone threatens each other with over the top threats, including the main charas lol
+ main lead almost had an interesting motive but of course Loving The Main Character takes precedence over any kind of dimensionality
+ male lead’s concept rubs me off the wrong way, vaguely ableist

11 10,2023

Second Life of a Trash Princess

 9.5(223 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s):
Genre(s): webtoons / Fantasy / Romance

4/5

pros/
+ in love w the art style and main chara’s fashion choices
+ the balance between magic and political schemings is well done! neither feel over the top… they both fit the tone of the story
+ the characters and character dynamics are just so likable heheh!!

cons/
+ no real themes but u kno… when thats the only bad thing i have to say abt an oi, thats pretty good imo LOL

12 10,2023

I'm A Stepmother, But My Daughter Is Just Too Cute!

 9.5(341 voted)
Ongoing
Author(s): Yir,Dinorex
Genre(s): Romance / Webtoons / Shoujo / fantasy

3/5

pros/
+ a cute mother/daughter relationship where the main chara uses her previous life’s sewing skills to dote on her daughter! such a cute premise
+ fashion is genuinely cute and thought out
+ male lead feels like a real chara and has a lot of reasons why he has Classic Black-Haired Lead Stoic Syndrome

cons/
+ magic system feels a lil silly LOL
+ no real themes, which surprised me since it is so obviously based off snow white

12 10,2023

What can a LIST do?

You may feel your favorite manga should be gathered together into distinct categories for your own reference and, now, you can do this with a LIST. After you've created your list or lists, you can proudly recommend them to other manga fans to showcase and share your taste in manga.

Messages

Superhappy5467 January 20, 2024 7:18 am

True, hating on stuff is the best hobby ever

yams January 20, 2024 11:12 pm

yes exactly. u get it