I do give very high ratings. My rating are based on my enjoyment towards the story, Characters Romance, and how much it engrossed me into it....... and also the art style too (but it actually doesn't matter much).
My ratings are:~ 5/5 (Loved it) 4.5/5 (This is good) 4/5 (I like it) 3.5/5 (Ok.... fine) 3/5 (Hmm....) 1-2/5 (Don't ask) 0/5 (I fucking regret reading this)